Can a Judge Overturn a Jury Verdict in Texas?
Yes, but only in limited ways. In a Texas civil case, a trial judge can take an issue from the jury, disregard a jury finding that has no support in the evidence, order a new trial for good cause, or suggest a remittitur, and a court of appeals can review the facts. This guide explains each path, the rule behind it and its deadlines.
- 138Google reviews
- 3Attorneys on your case
- 2 yrsTexas filing deadline
- No feeUnless we win
How a jury verdict becomes a judgment
The Texas Constitution provides that the right of trial by jury shall remain inviolate, and the Supreme Court of Texas opened its 2009 decision in In re Columbia Medical Center of Las Colinas by quoting that provision. How jurors reach a verdict is covered in the guide to jury deliberations and hung juries.
Rule 300 of the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure directs the court to render judgment on the verdict unless it is set aside, a new trial is granted, or judgment is rendered notwithstanding the verdict or a jury finding. Those exceptions, together with remittitur and appeal, are the main ways a verdict can be undone or changed. Columbia says a trial judge may not substitute a personal view for the jury's without a valid basis. Whether a case reaches a jury at all is discussed in how often personal injury cases go to trial, and related topics are in the Legal Guides hub.
Directed verdict: taking an issue from the jury
A motion for directed verdict asks the judge to decide a claim or an issue instead of sending it to the jury. Rule 268 is titled motion for instructed verdict, and its text uses the term directed verdict; it requires only that the motion state its specific grounds. Rule 301 allows judgment notwithstanding the verdict only if a directed verdict would have been proper, so the same question can be raised before and after the jury answers.
Judgment notwithstanding the verdict and disregarding jury findings
Rule 301 lets the court, on motion and reasonable notice, render judgment non obstante veredicto, the Latin phrase behind the abbreviation JNOV. The same rule lets the court, on like motion and notice, disregard any jury finding on a question that has no support in the evidence.
That is a no-evidence test, not a contest over which side had the stronger proof. Complaints about the weight of the evidence go through a motion for new trial instead.
After a judgment notwithstanding the findings, Rule 324(c) lets the party who obtained it raise by cross-point on appeal any ground that would have defeated the verdict, such as insufficient evidence. Grounds not raised this way are waived.
Ordering a new trial
Rule 320 allows a new trial for good cause, on a party's motion or on the court's own motion, including when the damages are manifestly too small or too large. A new trial may cover a clearly separable part of the case, but unliquidated damages alone may not be retried separately if liability is contested.
Rule 326 allows no more than two new trials to either party in the same case because of insufficiency or weight of the evidence. Rule 327 covers jury misconduct, improper communications with jurors and incorrect juror answers during jury selection. The court hears evidence and may grant a new trial if the matter was material and injury probably resulted to the complaining party.
In Columbia, a jury returned a unanimous defense verdict after a trial of nearly four weeks in a hospital death case, and the trial court granted a new trial in the interests of justice and fairness, without more. The Supreme Court of Texas, divided five to four, held that explanation insufficient. Reasons for setting aside a verdict must be clearly identified and reasonably specific, and the court conditionally granted mandamus relief directing the trial judge to state them.
The opinion added that good cause under Rule 320 does not mean just any cause. It did not decide whether that new trial was justified, because no reasons had yet been given.
Deadlines for a new trial and the court's plenary power
Rule 306a starts the clock on the date the judgment is signed, and Rule 329b sets the periods. A motion for new trial must be filed before or within 30 days after signing. A motion not decided by a signed written order within 75 days after the judgment is signed is overruled by operation of law.
The trial court has plenary power to grant a new trial or to vacate, modify, correct or reform the judgment for 30 days after signing. A timely motion for new trial extends that power until 30 days after all timely motions are overruled. After that, the judgment can be set aside only by bill of review, apart from clerical corrections and orders declaring a judgment void.
Under Rule 26.1 of the Texas Rules of Appellate Procedure, a notice of appeal is due 30 days after the judgment is signed, or 90 days if any party timely files a motion for new trial or a motion to modify the judgment. These periods help explain why the length of an injury case can extend past the verdict.
Remittitur and suggestions of remittitur
Remittitur means giving up part of an award. Under Rule 315, a party in whose favor judgment was rendered may remit any part of it in open court or by a signed, acknowledged written remittitur filed with the clerk, and execution then issues only for the balance.
A suggestion of remittitur comes from the judge and works as a condition: accept a reduced amount or face a new trial. Columbia describes the limit the Supreme Court of Texas set in Larson v. Cactus Utility Co. in 1987. A trial court may order a remittitur only when the evidence is factually insufficient to support the verdict, the same limit that applies to a court of appeals.
Appellate Rule 46.1 lets a party file a remittitur the trial court suggested in the court of appeals if the case was appealed first. Under Rule 46.2, a party who remitted at the trial judge's suggestion and then faces an appeal by the other side may still argue that the reduction was not required, but must perfect its own appeal. Limits fixed by statute, such as the medical malpractice damages cap, are a separate subject.
What a Texas court of appeals can do
Article V, Section 6 of the Texas Constitution makes a court of appeals' decision conclusive on all questions of fact brought before it.
Rule 324(b) requires a point in a motion for new trial before several complaints can be raised on appeal: factual insufficiency, a finding against the overwhelming weight of the evidence, inadequate or excessive damages, jury misconduct, newly discovered evidence and incurable jury argument not otherwise ruled on.
A court of appeals that reverses because a verdict is factually insufficient must, as Columbia explains, detail the relevant evidence and explain why it outweighs the evidence supporting the verdict, or why the verdict is so against the great weight and preponderance of the evidence that it is manifestly unjust. Under Appellate Rule 44.1, an error of law allows reversal only if it probably caused an improper judgment or probably prevented proper presentation of the appeal.
Under Appellate Rule 46.3, a court of appeals may suggest a remittitur; if it is timely filed, the court reforms and affirms the judgment, and if not, it reverses. Rule 46.4 keeps that determination out of evidence at any later trial. The personal injury claims overview explains how these cases are built.
Summary
Rule 300 requires judgment on the verdict unless it is set aside, a new trial is granted, or judgment is rendered notwithstanding the verdict. Under Rule 301, that judgment requires that a directed verdict would have been proper, and a finding can be disregarded only if it has no support in the evidence. A new trial needs good cause, must come within the plenary power set by Rule 329b, and under Columbia must rest on reasonably specific reasons. A court of appeals' decision is conclusive on questions of fact brought before it.
| Tool | Who acts | Standard or limit | Rule |
|---|---|---|---|
| Directed verdict | Trial judge, on a motion stating specific grounds | Same test later used for JNOV | TRCP 268, 301 |
| Judgment notwithstanding the verdict | Trial judge, on motion and notice | Only if a directed verdict would have been proper | TRCP 301 |
| Disregarding a jury finding | Trial judge, on motion and notice | No support in the evidence | TRCP 301 |
| New trial | Trial judge, on motion or its own motion, within plenary power | Good cause, with specific stated reasons; at most two for weight or insufficiency of the evidence | TRCP 320, 326, 327, 329b |
| Remittitur | Trial judge or court of appeals suggests; the winning party decides | A court-suggested remittitur only when the evidence is factually insufficient (Columbia, describing Larson) | TRCP 315; TRAP 46 |
| Appeal | Court of appeals | Conclusive on questions of fact; harmful error required for reversal | Tex. Const. art. V, sec. 6; TRCP 324; TRAP 44.1 |
Keep reading
Legal Guides
The core legal ideas behind a Texas injury claim, in plain language: what negligence means...
Guide hubHung Jury, Deliberations and Mistrials in Texas
A hung jury is a jury that cannot reach the agreement the law requires, and it ends the trial in a mistrial.
ReadWhat Is Vicarious Liability? The Texas Rules
Vicarious liability is a tort rule that makes one party legally responsible for another person's...
ReadDiminished Value Claims in Texas: Who Pays
A diminished value claim seeks the drop in a car's market value that remains after crash repairs.
ReadCedar Park Wrongful Death Lawyer
Texas injury representation for wrongful death.
Practice area
Frequently asked questions
Yes, in limited ways. In a Texas civil case, a judge can render judgment notwithstanding the verdict if a directed verdict would have been proper, disregard a jury finding with no support in the evidence, grant a new trial for good cause within the court's plenary power, or suggest a remittitur when the evidence does not support the full award.
A Texas judge can grant a new trial when damages are manifestly too small or too large, or suggest a remittitur, giving the winning party a choice between a reduced amount and a new trial. As described in the Columbia opinion, a trial court may order a remittitur only when the evidence is factually insufficient to support the verdict.
Under Rule 329b, a trial court has plenary power to grant a new trial for 30 days after the judgment is signed. A timely motion for new trial extends that power until 30 days after all timely motions are overruled, and a motion not decided by a signed written order within 75 days after signing is overruled by operation of law.
Yes. In In re Columbia Medical Center of Las Colinas (2009), the Supreme Court of Texas held that a trial court setting aside a jury verdict must give clearly identified, reasonably specific reasons. A bare statement that the new trial serves the interest of justice is not enough.
Yes. The Texas Constitution makes a court of appeals' decision conclusive on questions of fact, and the court reverses for an error of law only if it probably caused an improper judgment or probably prevented proper presentation of the appeal. Complaints such as factual insufficiency or excessive damages must first be raised in a motion for new trial.
The Valentine Law Firm handles Texas personal injury cases. This guide is general information about Texas law, not legal advice.
Was someone hurt in a crash?
If a collision or injury is behind your question, The Valentine Law Firm offers a free consultation on where you stand.
Contingency fee. You pay nothing unless we win.