What Is Voir Dire? Jury Selection in a Texas Civil Trial

Voir dire is the stage of a trial in which the judge and the lawyers question prospective jurors to find out whether they can decide the case fairly. In a Texas civil trial, the answers are used to remove jurors through challenges for cause and peremptory challenges. This guide explains each step, from the jury request to the oath.

  • 138Google reviews
  • 3Attorneys on your case
  • 2 yrsTexas filing deadline
  • No feeUnless we win

What voir dire means

Voir dire is a legal term that comes from French and is usually translated as "to speak the truth." It describes the questioning of prospective jurors to decide whether they are suitable to serve in a particular case. The same term is sometimes used for preliminary questions put to a witness, especially an expert, about competence to testify.

Texas uses the term in its court rules: Rule 223 of the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure refers to the "voir dire examination." Criminal trials use the same term but follow separate rules that this guide does not cover. Other court terms are explained in the firm's Texas legal guides.

A jury has to be requested first

A Texas civil case is not tried to a jury automatically. Under Rule 216, a party must file a written request with the clerk a reasonable time before the date set for trial on the non-jury docket, and not less than 30 days in advance. The rule sets a jury fee of ten dollars in district court and five dollars in county court unless other law provides otherwise.

A party who cannot afford the deposit may file an affidavit of inability under Rule 217. Rule 220 adds a trap: a party who fails to appear for trial waives the right to a jury. In justice court, Rule 504.1 requires a written jury demand no later than 14 days before the trial date and a fee of 22 dollars.

Jury selection itself comes late in a case, well after filing a personal injury lawsuit. A case that settles in direct talks or in mediation never reaches jury selection.

Who is qualified to serve on a Texas jury

Section 62.102 of the Texas Government Code lists the general qualifications. A juror must be at least 18, a United States citizen, a resident of Texas and of the county, and qualified to vote in that county. The person must also be of sound mind and good moral character, be able to read and write, and have no conviction or pending charge for misdemeanor theft or a felony.

Section 62.105 deals with a particular case. A person cannot sit as a juror if the person is a witness in the case, has a direct or indirect interest in its subject matter, is related to a party within the third degree, has a bias or prejudice for or against a party, or served as a juror in an earlier trial of the same case. Section 62.106 separately lists exemptions, which a qualified person may claim but does not have to.

Under Section 62.0132, a questionnaire developed by the Office of Court Administration accompanies the jury summons and asks for details such as age, education level and occupation. The completed form is confidential, but the judge, the litigants and their attorneys may see it.

The panel, the shuffle and the oath

The group of prospective jurors sent to a courtroom is called the panel. Where a county does not use interchangeable juries, Rule 224 has the clerk draw 24 names in district court or 12 in county court and give each side a list. The order of the list matters, because jurors are seated from the top down.

Texas therefore allows a jury shuffle. In counties with interchangeable juries, Rule 223 requires the trial judge, on the demand of any party made before voir dire, to have the panel members' names placed in a receptacle, shuffled and drawn again. Only one shuffle is permitted in each case.

Before questioning begins, Rule 226 requires the panel to swear to give true answers about their qualifications. The judge then reads the Rule 226a instructions, which tell panel members not to mingle with the lawyers, parties or witnesses. The instructions also explain that the lawyers may ask about a juror's background, experiences and attitudes in order to choose fair jurors.

What lawyers ask during voir dire

Questions are aimed at the grounds for removing a juror. In an injury case, lawyers may ask whether anyone knows the parties or the witnesses, or has been in a similar collision or lawsuit. They may also explore attitudes toward the issues the jury will decide, such as negligence and shared fault between the parties, whether the trial involves a car accident claim or another injury.

Some questions are off limits. Rule 230 bars any question whose answer may show that the juror has been convicted of a disqualifying offense or stands charged with theft or a felony.

Challenges for cause

Rule 227 recognizes two kinds of challenge to a juror: a challenge for cause and a peremptory challenge. Rule 228 defines a challenge for cause as an objection alleging a fact that by law disqualifies the person from serving in the case or in any case, or that in the court's opinion makes the person unfit to sit on the jury. Sections 62.102 and 62.105 supply those facts, including bias or prejudice for or against a party.

Rule 228 lets the judge hear other evidence for or against the challenge, and Rule 227 requires a decision without delay. Rule 233 limits only peremptory challenges, so the rules place no numeric cap on challenges for cause.

Peremptory challenges

A peremptory challenge, often called a strike, is made without giving any reason. Under Rule 232, the parties make these strikes once enough names remain that are not subject to a challenge for cause. Rule 233 gives each party six peremptory challenges in district court and three in county court.

Cases with several plaintiffs or defendants need an extra step. Rule 233 requires the judge to decide whether parties on the same side are antagonistic to each other on any issue the jury will decide. On a motion made before the strikes are used, the judge must equalize the challenges so that no litigant or side gains an unfair advantage.

"No reason" does not mean any reason. In Edmonson v. Leesville Concrete Co. (1991), the United States Supreme Court held that a private litigant in a civil case may not use peremptory challenges to exclude jurors on account of race.

How the jury is seated and sworn

Jury selection in Texas works by removal. After the strikes, each side returns its list to the clerk, and under Rule 234 the clerk calls the first 12 names that have not been erased in district court, or the first 6 in county court. If strikes leave too few names, Rule 235 has the court draw or summon more jurors.

Section 62.020 allows a district judge to add up to four alternate jurors and a county court judge up to two. Alternates replace, in order, any juror who becomes unable or disqualified to serve before deliberations begin. Each side receives one or two additional strikes that may be used only against alternates.

Rule 236 then requires the jurors to swear that they will render a true verdict according to the law and the evidence. What happens after the evidence closes is explained in the guide to jury deliberations, hung juries and mistrials. For wider context, see how many personal injury cases go to trial and the overview of a Texas personal injury claim.

Summary

Voir dire is the questioning of prospective jurors, and in a Texas civil trial it is governed by Rules 216 to 236 of the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure and Chapter 62 of the Government Code. A party must request a jury in writing a reasonable time before trial, and no later than 30 days before the trial setting. Jurors can be removed for cause when the law disqualifies them, including for bias or prejudice, and each party in district court also has six peremptory challenges. The first 12 names left on the list in district court, or the first 6 in county court, become the jury.

Ways a prospective juror can be moved or removed in a Texas civil trial
ToolWhat it doesLimitSource
Jury shuffleRedraws the order of the panel before questioning beginsOne shuffle per case, demanded before voir direRule 223
Challenge for causeRemoves a juror the law disqualifies or the court finds unfitNo numeric cap; the judge must agreeRules 227 to 229; Government Code 62.102 and 62.105
Peremptory challengeRemoves a juror without a stated reasonSix per party in district court, three in county court; not on account of raceRules 232 and 233; Edmonson v. Leesville Concrete Co.
Extra strikes for alternatesAdds strikes usable only against alternate jurorsOne per side for one or two alternates, two for three or fourGovernment Code 62.020

Frequently asked questions

Voir dire is a legal term from French, usually translated as "to speak the truth." It refers to the questioning of prospective jurors by the judge or the lawyers to decide whether each person is suitable to serve in a particular case. The term is also used for preliminary questioning of a witness, often an expert, about competence to testify.

Rule 233 of the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure gives each party six peremptory challenges in district court and three in county court. In cases with several parties, the judge decides how the parties are aligned and, on a timely motion, equalizes the strikes.

A challenge for cause asks the judge to remove a prospective juror because the law disqualifies the person or the court finds the person unfit, for example because of bias or prejudice toward a party. Texas rules set no number limit. A peremptory challenge needs no stated reason, but each party has a fixed number, and it cannot be used to exclude a juror on account of race.

A jury shuffle is a random reordering of the panel. Under Rule 223 of the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure, in counties that use interchangeable juries, any party may demand it before voir dire begins, and the trial judge then has the panel members' names shuffled and drawn again. Only one shuffle is allowed in each case. Order matters because jurors are seated from the top of the list.

Government Code Section 62.102 disqualifies anyone who is under 18, is not a United States citizen, does not live in the county, is not qualified to vote there, cannot read and write, or has a conviction or pending charge for misdemeanor theft or a felony. Section 62.105 also bars a person from a particular case for being a witness, a close relative of a party, or biased.

The Valentine Law Firm handles Texas personal injury cases. This guide is general information about Texas law, not legal advice.

Was someone hurt in a crash?

If a collision or injury is behind your question, The Valentine Law Firm offers a free consultation on where you stand.

Contingency fee. You pay nothing unless we win.

Call Now Free Consultation