What Is Vicarious Liability in Texas Injury Cases?

Vicarious liability is a tort rule that makes one party legally responsible for another person's negligence because of the relationship between them, even though the first party did nothing wrong itself. In Texas injury cases it usually means an employer answering for an employee who caused harm while doing the job. This guide explains the Texas test, the independent contractor exception and related rules.

  • 138Google reviews
  • 3Attorneys on your case
  • 2 yrsTexas filing deadline
  • No feeUnless we win

Vicarious liability and respondeat superior

Respondeat superior is the traditional name for vicarious liability in the employment setting. The Supreme Court of Texas describes it as a rule under which one person's fault is imputed to another who is entirely without fault, solely because of the relationship between them. Painter, quoting earlier authority, explains it as a deliberate allocation of risk to whoever is in a position to exercise general control.

The rule is an exception to the usual principle that a person has no duty to control someone else's conduct. It does not replace proof of fault. The employee's negligence still has to be established through the ordinary elements of negligence; vicarious liability only decides who else answers for it. Related concepts are collected in the Legal Guides hub.

The Texas test from Painter v. Amerimex Drilling

The leading Texas case is Painter v. Amerimex Drilling I, Ltd., 561 S.W.3d 125, decided by the Supreme Court of Texas in 2018. A driller was paid a daily bonus to drive his crew between a bunkhouse in Fort Stockton and a well site about 30 miles away. Driving the crew back after a shift in 2007, he struck another vehicle, and two crew members died.

The injured worker and the families sued the drilling company. The trial court ruled for the company on summary judgment and the court of appeals agreed. The Supreme Court of Texas reversed and sent the case back, holding that a fact question existed on whether the driller was acting in the course and scope of his employment.

The court set out a two-step test. The injured person must show that, at the time of the negligent conduct, the worker (1) was an employee and (2) was acting in the course and scope of employment. Two justices dissented.

When a worker is acting in the course and scope of employment

Painter describes the course-and-scope question as objective. The issue is whether the employee was performing the tasks generally assigned to him in furtherance of the employer's business, acting with the employer's authority and for the employer's benefit. If an employee deviates from those duties for personal purposes, the employer is not responsible for what happens during the deviation, and Painter adds that this is true even when the employer permitted the personal use.

The court confirmed that the coming-and-going rule applies to vicarious liability: an employee generally is not acting within the scope of employment while traveling to and from work. The exception is travel that involves regular or specifically assigned duties for the employer's benefit. Painter held that when a specifically assigned duty includes driving other workers to the workplace, it "necessarily also includes ensuring they are not left stranded", and there was evidence the driller had that duty. The same line runs through many work-related car accident claims.

Painter also said the workers' compensation proceedings in that case did not decide the vicarious liability question, which is the one that matters in a car accident claim against an employer.

Independent contractors and the right to control

As a general rule, a company is not liable for the negligence of its independent contractors. What separates an employee from an independent contractor is the employer's overall right to control the progress, details and methods of the work, whether or not it chooses to exercise that right on a particular task. Painter, quoting its earlier Limestone Products decision, lists five factors: the independent nature of the worker's business, who supplies the tools and materials, the worker's control of the work apart from the final result, the length of the engagement, and whether pay is by time or by the job.

Painter rejected a task-by-task review of an admitted employee's status. Control remains task-specific in two other settings the court described. A company that hires a contractor but retains some control over the manner of the work that causes the harm can face supervisory liability. A general employee placed under another company's direction and control can become that company's borrowed employee.

These questions arise often in truck accident claims; the practical sorting of carriers and owner-operators is covered in who is liable for a Texas truck accident.

Rideshare drivers under Texas law

Occupations Code Section 2402.114 says a driver authorized to log in to a transportation network company's digital network is an independent contractor for all purposes, and not an employee in any manner, if two things are true.

First, the company does not prescribe the specific hours the driver must be logged in, restrict the driver from using other companies' apps, limit the territory where the driver may give rides, or restrict the driver from other work. Second, the company and the driver agree in writing that the driver is an independent contractor. When both conditions are met, the driver is an independent contractor, so the general rule protecting companies from their contractors' negligence applies to a rideshare accident claim.

Government employees, parents and bars

A government employer can also answer for its employee's driving. Civil Practice and Remedies Code Section 101.021(1) makes a governmental unit liable for injury and death caused by the negligence of an employee acting within the scope of employment when the harm arises from the operation or use of a motor-driven vehicle or equipment and the employee would be personally liable to the claimant under Texas law. The notice rules and caps are explained in the guide to the Texas Tort Claims Act.

For parents, Family Code Section 41.001 imposes liability for property damage caused by a child's negligent conduct that is reasonably attributable to the parent's failure to exercise the duty of control, or by the wilful and malicious conduct of a child at least 10 but under 18. Section 41.002 caps recovery for wilful and malicious conduct at 25,000 dollars per occurrence, plus fees, costs and expenses. Chapter 41 speaks only of property damage.

Some relationships do not create vicarious liability at all. Painter, describing an earlier decision, notes that the relationship between a bar and its customer lacks the right of control and that the Dram Shop Act does not impose vicarious liability. A Texas dram shop claim is a separate claim under that Act.

How vicarious liability differs from direct negligence claims

A vicarious liability claim says the company answers for its employee's fault because of the employment relationship. A direct claim, such as negligent hiring, supervision or entrustment, says the company itself was careless and has to be proved with evidence of the company's own conduct. Depending on the facts, a company can face one theory, both or neither.

What vicarious liability means for an injured person

The evidence the court relied on in Painter included the contract creating the driving bonus, the driller's testimony that driving the crew was his job, and the absence of any personal detour at the time of the crash.

Suing the employer does not extend the two-year deadline, and claims against a governmental employer also carry separate notice rules. Civil Practice and Remedies Code Section 16.003 generally requires a personal injury suit to be filed within two years after the cause of action accrues, under the same Texas statute of limitations. Whether a particular employer is responsible depends on the facts, and Painter itself held only that a fact question existed, not that the employer was liable.

Summary

Vicarious liability, also called respondeat superior, lets an injured person hold an employer responsible for an employee's negligence without proving the employer was at fault. Under the 2018 Painter decision of the Supreme Court of Texas, the injured person must show the worker was an employee and was acting in the course and scope of employment when the negligence happened. Independent contractors, including rideshare drivers who meet Occupations Code Section 2402.114, generally fall outside the rule. Direct claims against a company for its own carelessness are a separate theory with their own proof.

Questions Texas courts ask in a vicarious liability claim
QuestionFacts that support the injured personFacts that support the defendant
Was the worker an employee?Overall right to control the details of the workIndependent business, own tools, paid by the job
Was the worker doing the job?Performing generally assigned tasks for the employer's benefitA personal errand or other deviation
Was the worker commuting?The trip was an assigned duty, such as driving the crewAn ordinary commute (coming-and-going rule)
Was the driver on a rideshare app?A Section 2402.114 condition is missing (ordinary right-to-control test applies)All Section 2402.114 conditions are met
Was a contractor doing the work?Hiring company kept control over how the harmful work was doneHiring company controlled only the result

Frequently asked questions

Vicarious liability means one party is held legally responsible for someone else's negligence because of their relationship, even if the first party did nothing wrong. The most common example is an employer answering for an employee who caused an injury while doing the job. In Texas the injured person must show the worker was an employee and was acting in the course and scope of employment at the time.

A delivery driver who runs a red light while making a delivery and injures another motorist is a typical illustration. The driver was doing assigned work for the employer's benefit, so the employer can be held responsible for the driver's negligence. If the same driver caused the crash during a personal errand or the ordinary drive home, Texas law would generally treat it differently.

Usually not. Under the coming-and-going rule, which the Supreme Court of Texas applied to vicarious liability in Painter v. Amerimex Drilling I, Ltd. (2018), an employee generally is not acting within the scope of employment while traveling to and from work. The exception covers travel that involves regular or specifically assigned duties for the employer, such as a worker paid to drive the crew to and from a job site.

Generally no. Texas law insulates a company from liability for the negligence of its independent contractors, and the dividing line is the right to control the details of the work. A company that retains some control over how a contractor does the work can face supervisory liability, and a worker labeled a contractor may still be an employee if the company held the overall right of control.

Texas Family Code Chapter 41 makes a parent liable for property damage caused by a child's negligent conduct when it results from the parent's failure to exercise the duty of control, or by the wilful and malicious conduct of a child aged 10 to 17. Recovery for wilful and malicious conduct is limited to 25,000 dollars per occurrence plus fees, costs and expenses. The statute addresses property damage only.

The Valentine Law Firm handles Texas personal injury cases. This guide is general information about Texas law, not legal advice.

Was someone hurt in a crash?

If a collision or injury is behind your question, The Valentine Law Firm offers a free consultation on where you stand.

Contingency fee. You pay nothing unless we win.

Call Now Free Consultation