What Is the Texas Medical Malpractice Cap on Damages?
Texas limits noneconomic damages in a medical malpractice case to 250,000 dollars per claimant against physicians and other providers that are not institutions, and to as much as 500,000 dollars per claimant against hospitals and other institutions. Economic damages are not capped in an injury case. This guide explains each limit, the separate wrongful death cap, and how the limits work with several defendants.
- 138Google reviews
- 3Attorneys on your case
- 2 yrsTexas filing deadline
- No feeUnless we win
The three limits in Section 74.301
The main Texas medical malpractice cap sits in Section 74.301 of the Civil Practice and Remedies Code. It applies to a health care liability claim, which Section 74.001 defines as a claim against a physician or health care provider for treatment, lack of treatment, or another departure from accepted standards of care that causes injury or death. The section limits one category of compensation only: noneconomic damages.
Section 74.301 sets three limits. First, when the judgment is against a physician or a health care provider that is not an institution, noneconomic damages are limited to 250,000 dollars for each claimant. Second, when the judgment is against a single health care institution, the limit is also 250,000 dollars for each claimant. Third, when the judgment is against more than one institution, each institution is limited to 250,000 dollars and all institutions together to 500,000 dollars for each claimant.
Section 74.001 lists what counts as a health care institution, including hospitals, hospital systems, nursing homes, ambulatory surgical centers, hospices and assisted living facilities. Nurses, dentists, pharmacists and chiropractors fall on the provider side of the line with physicians.
The figures are fixed. Section 74.301 has no inflation adjustment, and the amounts are the ones the Legislature enacted in 2003. Other Legal Guides explain the fault rules that decide whether any damages are owed.
What the cap covers and what it leaves alone
Chapter 74 borrows its damages definitions from Section 41.001. Noneconomic damages compensate for physical pain and suffering, mental or emotional anguish, loss of consortium, disfigurement, physical impairment, loss of companionship and society, inconvenience and loss of enjoyment of life.
Economic damages are compensation for actual economic or pecuniary loss. Past and future medical bills, lost wages and lost earning capacity belong here, and Section 74.301 does not limit them in an injury case. A separate guide covers these special damages in a personal injury case.
The effect falls unevenly. A retiree, a child or a stay-at-home parent may have a claim that is mostly noneconomic and therefore mostly capped, while future care costs in a medical malpractice brain injury claim stay outside the limit.
One claimant, one cap
The limits apply for each claimant, and Chapter 74 defines that word narrowly. Under Section 74.001, all persons claiming damages from the bodily injury or death of a single person are considered a single claimant. A decedent's estate is included.
A family therefore does not multiply the cap. An injured patient and a spouse claiming loss of consortium share one limit, as do a surviving spouse, children and parents who bring claims over one death.
How the cap applies with multiple defendants
Adding more physicians or other non-institution providers does not raise that limit. Section 74.301 says the 250,000 dollar limit for physicians and other non-institution providers applies regardless of the number of those defendants or the number of separate causes of action. A surgeon, an anesthesiologist and a nurse sued together share one 250,000 dollar limit.
Each limit is also written to include all persons and entities for which vicarious liability theories may apply.
The institution limits are separate from the physician limit. Reading the three subsections together, the most a claimant can receive in noneconomic damages is 250,000 dollars from physicians and other non-institution providers plus 500,000 dollars from two or more institutions, or 750,000 dollars in all.
The separate cap on wrongful death and survival claims
Section 74.303 adds a different limit when the patient dies. In a wrongful death or survival action on a health care liability claim, liability for all damages, including exemplary damages, is limited to 500,000 dollars for each claimant.
Unlike Section 74.301, this limit is indexed. The statute adjusts the 500,000 dollar figure by the percentage change in the consumer price index, as published by the federal Bureau of Labor Statistics, between August 29, 1977 and the date damages are awarded by final judgment or settlement. The figure in force therefore changes over time and has to be calculated for the date of the judgment or settlement.
Section 74.303 also carves out one category. The limit does not apply to the expenses of necessary medical, hospital and custodial care received before judgment or required in the future. Section 74.301 is written to apply to any health care liability claim, so in a death case the noneconomic limit and the overall limit can both come into play. Related guides explain wrongful death claims based on medical malpractice and the difference between a survival action and a wrongful death claim.
Where the Legislature's authority comes from
Texas voters amended the state constitution in 2003 to authorize these limits. Article III, Section 66 of the Texas Constitution, added on September 13, 2003, says the Legislature may by statute determine the limit of liability for all damages other than economic damages against a provider of medical or health care.
The Legislature also wrote a backup. Section 74.302 is an alternative limitation that takes effect only if Section 74.301 is struck down by something other than legislative action. It repeats the same limits for physicians and providers who show evidence of financial responsibility, such as liability insurance.
Hypothetical illustration: how a verdict is reduced
The following example is a hypothetical illustration, not a real case or a prediction. A patient is injured during surgery and sues the surgeon and the hospital. A jury finds both negligent and awards 900,000 dollars in economic damages for medical care and lost earnings and 1,200,000 dollars in noneconomic damages.
The jury never hears about the cap. Section 74.303 requires the court to instruct jurors not to consider or speculate about whether any liability is subject to a limit. The limits then cap the amount of the judgment.
The economic award of 900,000 dollars is untouched. The noneconomic award cannot exceed 250,000 dollars against the surgeon and 250,000 dollars against the single hospital, so no more than 500,000 dollars of the 1,200,000 dollars can appear in the judgment. The most the judgment could total is 1,400,000 dollars instead of 2,100,000 dollars. Other rules, not covered here, decide how that amount is divided between the defendants.
Exemplary damages, deadlines and scope
Exemplary damages, also called punitive damages, are a separate category. Section 41.001 says they are neither economic nor noneconomic, so Section 74.301 does not address them. They have their own limit in Section 41.008: the greater of 200,000 dollars, or two times economic damages plus the noneconomic damages found by the jury up to 750,000 dollars. In a death case, Section 74.303 counts exemplary damages inside its overall limit. The guide to gross negligence versus ordinary negligence explains the conduct exemplary damages are aimed at.
The caps apply only to health care liability claims. A car wreck or fall claim handled by a Texas personal injury lawyer against someone who is not a health care provider is not subject to Section 74.301.
Malpractice claims also run on their own clock. Section 74.251 generally requires suit within two years from the breach or tort, or from the date the treatment at issue was completed, a rule covered with other deadlines in the guide to the Texas statute of limitations. Fault itself still turns on the elements of negligence.
Summary
The Texas medical malpractice cap is a set of limits in Chapter 74 of the Civil Practice and Remedies Code. Noneconomic damages are limited to 250,000 dollars per claimant against physicians and other non-institution providers, 250,000 dollars against one institution, and 500,000 dollars against all institutions combined. Economic damages such as medical bills and lost earnings have no cap in an injury case. Death cases face a separate limit on all damages that starts at 500,000 dollars and moves with the consumer price index.
| Situation | Limit for each claimant | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Judgment against physicians or other non-institution providers (any number) | 250,000 dollars in noneconomic damages | Sec. 74.301(a) |
| Judgment against one health care institution | 250,000 dollars in noneconomic damages | Sec. 74.301(b) |
| Judgment against two or more institutions | 250,000 dollars each, 500,000 dollars combined, in noneconomic damages | Sec. 74.301(c) |
| Wrongful death or survival claim | 500,000 dollars base for all damages, adjusted by the consumer price index since August 29, 1977; medical, hospital and custodial care expenses excluded | Sec. 74.303 |
| Economic damages in an injury case | No cap | Sec. 74.301; Sec. 41.001 |
| Exemplary damages | Greater of 200,000 dollars, or two times economic damages plus noneconomic damages up to 750,000 dollars | Sec. 41.008(b) |
Keep reading
Legal Guides
The core legal ideas behind a Texas injury claim, in plain language: what negligence means...
Guide hubGross Negligence vs Ordinary Negligence in Texas
Ordinary negligence is carelessness, like a driver who was not paying attention.
ReadTexas Tort Claims Act: Notice, Caps and Who Can Sue
The Texas Tort Claims Act is the state law that decides when an injured person can sue a governmental unit.
ReadThe Four Elements of Negligence in Texas
To hold someone responsible for an injury in Texas, you have to prove four things: that they owed you...
ReadCedar Park Wrongful Death Lawyer
Texas injury representation for wrongful death.
Practice area
Frequently asked questions
Texas caps noneconomic damages in medical malpractice cases under Civil Practice and Remedies Code Section 74.301. The limit is 250,000 dollars per claimant against physicians and other non-institution providers, 250,000 dollars per claimant against a single health care institution, and 500,000 dollars per claimant against all institutions combined. Economic damages such as medical bills and lost income are not capped in an injury case.
Section 74.303 limits all damages, including exemplary damages, in a wrongful death or survival claim based on medical malpractice. The base figure is 500,000 dollars per claimant, and the statute adjusts it by the change in the consumer price index since August 29, 1977, so the amount in force is higher and changes over time. Necessary medical, hospital and custodial care expenses fall outside the limit.
No. Section 74.301 applies the 250,000 dollar limit for physicians and other non-institution providers regardless of how many of them are defendants. The limit for institutions is separate, so a judgment against a doctor and two or more hospitals can reach 750,000 dollars in noneconomic damages for one claimant. Family members claiming over the same patient's injury count as a single claimant.
Not in an injury case. Section 74.301 limits only noneconomic damages such as pain, mental anguish, disfigurement and physical impairment. Compensation for actual financial loss, including past and future medical care and lost earning capacity, has no statutory limit. In a death case, Section 74.303 limits all damages but still excludes necessary medical, hospital and custodial care expenses.
Article III, Section 66 of the Texas Constitution expressly authorizes it. Article III, Section 66, added on September 13, 2003, allows the Legislature to set the limit of liability for damages other than economic damages against medical and health care providers. The Legislature also enacted Section 74.302 as a backup limit that would take effect if Section 74.301 were ever invalidated.
The Valentine Law Firm handles Texas personal injury cases. This guide is general information about Texas law, not legal advice.
Was someone hurt in a crash?
If a collision or injury is behind your question, The Valentine Law Firm offers a free consultation on where you stand.
Contingency fee. You pay nothing unless we win.