Texas Impairment Ratings and Statutory MMI: How the Date and the Weeks Are Counted
Statutory MMI in Texas is a date set by rule, not a calculator. MMI is reached 104 weeks after income benefits begin to accrue, unless a doctor certifies it earlier or spinal surgery extends it. The impairment rating assigned at that point pays three weeks of impairment income benefits for each percentage point. This guide explains both counts, who assigns the rating, and how to dispute it.
- 138Google reviews
- 3Attorneys on your case
- 2 yrsTexas filing deadline
- No feeUnless we win
What maximum medical improvement means in Texas
Labor Code Section 401.011(30) defines maximum medical improvement, or MMI, as the earlier of three dates. The first is the earliest date after which, based on reasonable medical probability, further material recovery from or lasting improvement to an injury can no longer reasonably be anticipated. The second is the expiration of 104 weeks from the date income benefits begin to accrue. The third is a date set under Section 408.104 after spinal surgery.
The Division of Workers' Compensation at the Texas Department of Insurance calls the first date clinical MMI and the 104-week date statutory MMI on its Report of Medical Evaluation, DWC Form-069. MMI matters because temporary income benefits continue only until the employee reaches it under Section 408.102. The form itself notes that reaching either kind of MMI does not signify the end of medical benefits. The other benefit types, wage calculations and claim deadlines are covered in the guide to Texas workers' compensation benefits.
How the statutory MMI date is worked out
A statutory MMI calculator performs one addition. The starting point is the date income benefits began to accrue, not the date of injury. Under Section 408.082, if a disability lasts longer than one week, weekly income benefits begin to accrue on the eighth day after the injury. If the disability starts later, they accrue on the eighth day after the disability began.
Statutory MMI is 104 weeks after that accrual date. Division training materials for designated doctors say the statutory date is listed on the DWC Form-032 that requests a designated doctor examination, the designated doctor does not determine it, and it does not apply to a claim in which income benefits never started.
Under Section 408.104, the commissioner may extend the 104-week period if the employee has had spinal surgery, or has been approved for it, within 12 weeks before the period expires. The order extends statutory MMI to a date certain based on medical evidence.
Who certifies MMI and assigns the impairment rating
Section 401.011 defines impairment as an anatomic or functional abnormality or loss that exists after MMI, results from a compensable injury and is reasonably presumed to be permanent. The impairment rating is the percentage of permanent impairment of the whole body. Under Section 408.123, the doctor who certifies MMI evaluates the employee and assigns the rating, then sends a written report to the Division, the employee and the insurance carrier.
DWC Form-069 lists the doctors who may file that report: the treating doctor, a doctor selected by the treating doctor, a designated doctor selected by the Division, and in limited cases a doctor selected by the insurance carrier. When a worker has permanent impairment, the form states that only a doctor certified by the Division to assign impairment ratings, or one granted specific permission, may certify MMI and assign the rating.
The rating must rest on evidence. Section 408.122 bars impairment income benefits unless evidence of impairment based on an objective clinical or laboratory finding exists.
The AMA Guides behind the percentage
Impairment income benefits turn on a rating of the whole body, not on a list of payouts for each body part. Section 408.124 requires every award to be based on a rating determined under the American Medical Association's Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment. The statute names the third edition and allows the commissioner to adopt the fourth edition or a later one by rule.
The Division's designated doctor program page tells designated doctors to use the fourth edition only, and the Division has proposed moving to the sixth edition, so the current rule is worth checking. DWC Form-069 also draws a line: a finding of no impairment is not the same as a zero percent rating, because a doctor can assign any rating, including zero, only after performing the examination and testing the Guides require.
Counting the weeks of impairment income benefits
Section 408.121 sets the formula. Entitlement to impairment income benefits begins the day after the employee reaches MMI and runs for three weeks for each percentage point of impairment. The carrier must begin paying no later than the fifth day after it receives the doctor's report certifying MMI.
Hypothetical illustration: a warehouse worker is hurt in a fall and stays off work. Income benefits begin to accrue on the eighth day after the injury, so statutory MMI would arrive 104 weeks after that day. Her doctor instead certifies clinical MMI in week 60 after benefits began to accrue and assigns a 12 percent whole body rating. Twelve points times three weeks equals 36 weeks of impairment income benefits, starting the day after the MMI date.
Two points sit on top of the formula. If the carrier disputes the rating, Section 408.121 has it pay for a period based on its reasonable assessment of the correct rating while the dispute is pending. The weekly amount is a separate question, set at 70 percent of the average weekly wage under Section 408.126, subject to a maximum and minimum.
Disputing an MMI date or impairment rating
Under Section 408.123, the first valid certification of MMI and the first valid impairment rating become final if not disputed before the 91st day after written notice is provided to the employee and the carrier by verifiable means. Later disputes require compelling medical evidence of a significant error in applying the Guides or calculating the rating, a clearly mistaken diagnosis or previously undiagnosed condition, or improper or inadequate treatment before the certification that would make it invalid, or other compelling circumstances defined by Division rule.
DWC Form-069 tells injured employees to dispute by contacting the Division to request a designated doctor, if one has not been appointed, or a benefit review conference. When a rating is disputed, Section 408.125 sends the employee to the next available doctor on the Division's designated doctor list. Section 408.0041 requires the examination no later than the 21st day after the commissioner's order. The report has presumptive weight unless the preponderance of the other medical evidence is to the contrary.
The 15 percent line and supplemental income benefits
Section 408.142 makes an employee eligible for supplemental income benefits when the impairment income benefit period ends only if the rating is 15 percent or more. The employee must also have not returned to work, or be earning less than 80 percent of the average weekly wage as a direct result of the impairment, and must meet work search requirements.
One choice can close that door. Section 408.128 lets an employee who has been back at work for at least three months, earning at least 80 percent of the average weekly wage, commute the remaining impairment income benefits. An employee who commutes is not entitled to additional income benefits for the injury.
How a rating fits with a negligence claim against a third party
An impairment rating measures benefits inside the workers' compensation system only. Section 408.001 makes those benefits the exclusive remedy against a covered employer, but Section 417.001 allows an employee to seek damages from a liable third party and pursue compensation benefits as well. Common examples are a work-related car accident caused by another driver, or a job site injury caused by a different contractor, the kind of claim the construction accident lawyer page covers.
In that separate claim, the rating does not set the value. The injured person must prove the elements of negligence, and the recovery turns on the damages available in a Texas injury claim rather than on weeks per percentage point. The carrier that paid benefits also has a reimbursement right against that recovery under Section 417.001.
Related pages apply these ideas to a rotator cuff injury at work and a slip and fall at work. More explanations are collected in the Legal Guides hub.
Summary
Maximum medical improvement in Texas workers' compensation is the earlier of the clinical date a doctor certifies or the statutory date, 104 weeks after income benefits begin to accrue. The certifying doctor then assigns a whole body impairment rating under the AMA Guides, and Labor Code Section 408.121 converts each percentage point into three weeks of impairment income benefits. A first certification becomes final unless it is disputed before the 91st day after written notice, and a designated doctor's report carries presumptive weight in a dispute. A rating of 15 percent or more is one of the conditions for supplemental income benefits.
| Impairment rating | Weeks of benefits (rating times 3) | Rating condition for supplemental income benefits |
|---|---|---|
| 5 percent | 15 weeks | Not met (below 15 percent) |
| 10 percent | 30 weeks | Not met (below 15 percent) |
| 15 percent | 45 weeks | Met; the other conditions still apply |
| 20 percent | 60 weeks | Met; the other conditions still apply |
Keep reading
Legal Guides
The core legal ideas behind a Texas injury claim, in plain language: what negligence means...
Guide hubWhen Does Workers' Comp Start Paying in Texas?
Texas workers' comp income benefits begin after a one-week waiting period.
ReadVoir Dire: How Jury Selection Works in Texas
Voir dire is the stage of a trial in which the judge and the lawyers question prospective jurors to find out whether they can decide the case fairly.
ReadTexas Medical Malpractice Cap: Damages Limits
Texas limits noneconomic damages in a medical malpractice case to 250,000 dollars per claimant against...
ReadCedar Park Wrongful Death Lawyer
Texas injury representation for wrongful death.
Practice area
Frequently asked questions
Statutory MMI is the expiration of 104 weeks from the date income benefits begin to accrue under Labor Code Section 401.011(30). Weekly income benefits usually begin to accrue on the eighth day after the injury, or the eighth day after disability begins if it starts later. The Division's training materials say the date is listed on the DWC Form-032.
Labor Code Section 408.121 pays impairment income benefits for three weeks for each percentage point of impairment, beginning the day after maximum medical improvement. A 10 percent rating means 30 weeks and a 20 percent rating means 60 weeks. The weekly amount is a separate calculation, 70 percent of the employee's average weekly wage, so the rating fixes the number of weeks, not the amount of each payment.
Under Labor Code Section 408.123, the first valid certification of maximum medical improvement and the first valid impairment rating become final if they are not disputed before the 91st day after written notice is provided to the employee and the carrier. After that, a dispute requires compelling medical evidence of specific problems, such as a significant error in applying the AMA Guides or a clearly mistaken diagnosis, or other compelling circumstances defined by Division rule.
Labor Code Section 408.142 requires an impairment rating of 15 percent or more. The employee must also have not returned to work, or be earning less than 80 percent of the average weekly wage as a direct result of the impairment, must not have commuted impairment income benefits, and must comply with work search requirements.
Reaching maximum medical improvement ends temporary income benefits under Labor Code Section 408.102, but it is not a cutoff for medical care. The Division's Report of Medical Evaluation, DWC Form-069, states that reaching either clinical or statutory MMI does not signify that the employee is no longer entitled to medical benefits.
The Valentine Law Firm handles Texas personal injury cases. This guide is general information about Texas law, not legal advice.
Was someone hurt in a crash?
If a collision or injury is behind your question, The Valentine Law Firm offers a free consultation on where you stand.
Contingency fee. You pay nothing unless we win.