Texas Workers' Comp Disputes: The Benefit Review Conference and What Comes Next
When a Texas workers' compensation carrier denies or disputes a claim, the first formal step is usually a benefit review conference, an informal meeting run by the state's Division of Workers' Compensation. Unresolved issues then go to a contested case hearing or arbitration, an appeals panel and, finally, court. This guide explains each step and the deadlines that apply.
- 138Google reviews
- 3Attorneys on your case
- 2 yrsTexas filing deadline
- No feeUnless we win
How a Texas workers' comp dispute starts
A dispute is any disagreement between the injured employee and the insurance carrier about a claim. The Texas Department of Insurance lists common ones as whether the injury happened in the course and scope of employment, exceptions such as intoxication or horseplay, income benefits, the average weekly wage, and death benefits. The benefits themselves are explained in the guide to Texas workers' comp benefits.
Chapter 410 of the Labor Code sets the steps that follow. The Division of Workers' Compensation, part of the Texas Department of Insurance, runs every stage except the last, which happens in court. Related topics are in the Legal Guides hub.
Requesting a benefit review conference
Section 410.024 says the parties to a disputed claim are generally not entitled to a contested case hearing or arbitration unless a benefit review conference has been held. Under Section 410.023, the party asking for the conference must show what it did to resolve the dispute first, and the Division may deny a request that lacks that documentation.
The Texas Department of Insurance directs parties to use DWC Form-045, the request to schedule, reschedule or cancel a benefit review conference, and to attach records such as letters or emails showing the attempts to settle the issue. The requester sends its pertinent information to the other parties before filing. A party that receives a request has 10 days to share its own information, and each party sends its information to the Division at least 14 days before the conference.
What happens at the benefit review conference
Section 410.021 describes the conference as a nonadversarial, informal proceeding meant to explain each side's rights, sort out the disputed issues and mediate an agreement. A benefit review officer employed by the Division leads it. Under Section 410.026, the officer cannot take testimony or make a formal record, which makes the meeting closer to mediation than to a trial. The Department says conferences are held by videoconference.
Any agreement is put in writing and signed by the officer and the parties under Section 410.029. Section 410.030 makes it binding on the carrier, and on a claimant who has an attorney to the same extent. An unrepresented claimant is bound while the claim is pending before the Division unless the commissioner relieves the claimant for good cause. Issues left unresolved go into a written report under Section 410.031 that lists each side's position and the date of the contested case hearing. Under Section 410.032, the officer can also consider a request for an interlocutory order on the payment of benefits while the dispute continues.
Attendance matters. Section 410.028 says the conference goes ahead even if a party does not appear, and a party who fails to attend without good cause forfeits the right to a conference on that issue.
Arbitration as an alternative
If issues remain after the conference, both parties can agree to arbitration instead of a contested case hearing. Section 410.104 requires the election to be filed with the Division within 20 days after the last day of the conference, and the choice is irrevocable. Under Section 410.119, the arbitrator's award is final and binding, and Section 410.121 lets a court vacate it only on narrow grounds such as fraud.
The contested case hearing
Without an arbitration election, unresolved issues go to a contested case hearing. Section 410.025(b) requires the Division to set the hearing for a date no later than 60 days after the conference. An administrative law judge presides, swears witnesses, takes testimony and allows cross-examination. Section 410.0055, added in 2025, lets the Division hold a hearing by videoconference for good cause or by agreement of the parties.
Two rules catch unprepared parties. Section 410.151(b) bars an issue that was not raised at the conference unless the parties consent or good cause is shown. Section 410.161 keeps out evidence a party failed to disclose when required, unless good cause is shown. The judge issues a written decision with findings of fact, conclusions of law and any award of benefits, and Section 410.169 makes it final unless a party appeals in time.
Appealing to the appeals panel
Section 410.202 gives a party 15 days after receiving the judge's decision to file a written request for appeal, serving the other party the same day. The other side has 15 days to respond. Saturdays, Sundays and listed state holidays do not count. The Department explains that when the decision arrives by regular mail, the period starts five days after the mailing date, and that the panel will not consider a late appeal or response.
The panel holds no new hearing; it reviews the record and the written filings. Section 410.204 requires a written decision within 45 days after the response is filed in a reversed or remanded case, and the panel writes an opinion affirming a decision only in limited situations. If no decision issues in accordance with that section, the judge's decision becomes final and stands as the panel's decision.
Judicial review in court
A party that has used every step and disagrees with the final panel decision can seek judicial review under Section 410.251. Section 410.252 requires suit within 45 days after the Division mailed the decision, with the mailing date treated as the fifth day after the decision was filed with the Division. That is far shorter than the two-year deadline for most injury lawsuits. For most injuries the petition goes to a court in the county where the employee lived when injured, and Section 410.253 requires a copy to be provided to the Division.
For compensability and income or death benefits, Sections 410.301 to 410.304 let the court or jury decide the issues anew, limited to those the panel decided. The appealing party carries the burden of proof by a preponderance of the evidence, and a jury is told what the panel decided. The Supreme Court of Texas called this modified de novo review in Texas Workers' Compensation Commission v. Garcia, 893 S.W.2d 504 (Tex. 1995).
All other issues are decided by the court under the narrower substantial evidence rule in Section 410.255. For compensability and income or death benefit issues, the case moves much like a personal injury lawsuit, up to jury deliberation.
When a separate injury claim is possible
The dispute process decides benefits from the carrier only. Section 417.001 allows an injured employee to claim workers' compensation and also seek damages from a third party whose negligence caused the injury, such as another driver in a work-related car accident or an outside contractor on a construction site. The carrier is reimbursed from that recovery, and the case runs separately as a personal injury claim.
Summary
Texas resolves workers' compensation disputes through a fixed sequence set out in Labor Code Chapter 410. A benefit review conference comes first and is generally required before a contested case hearing or arbitration. A party who loses at the hearing has 15 days after receiving the decision, not counting weekends and listed holidays, to ask the appeals panel for review. A party who disagrees with the final appeals panel decision can file suit within 45 days after the Division mailed it.
| Step | What happens | Deadline or timing | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Try to resolve it | The employee or carrier raises the issue with the other side and shares pertinent information. | Before asking for a conference; the request must document these efforts. | Labor Code Section 410.023; Texas Department of Insurance |
| 2. Request a conference | A party files DWC Form-045 and copies the other parties. | Receiving party shares its information within 10 days; all parties file with the Division at least 14 days before the conference. | Texas Department of Insurance |
| 3. Benefit review conference | A benefit review officer mediates; agreements are signed, unresolved issues go in a report. | Scheduling time is set by commissioner rule. | Sections 410.021 to 410.031 |
| 4. Arbitration (optional) | Both parties elect binding arbitration instead of a hearing. | Election filed within 20 days after the last day of the conference. | Section 410.104 |
| 5. Contested case hearing | An administrative law judge hears testimony and issues a written decision. | Held no later than 60 days after the conference. | Sections 410.025(b) and 410.168 |
| 6. Appeals panel | Three appeals judges review the record and written filings. | Appeal within 15 days of receiving the decision, response within 15 days of service, weekends and listed holidays excluded. | Sections 410.202 and 410.204 |
| 7. Judicial review | Suit in the county where the employee lived when injured. | Within 45 days after the Division mailed the panel decision. | Sections 410.252 and 410.301 to 410.304 |
Keep reading
Legal Guides
The core legal ideas behind a Texas injury claim, in plain language: what negligence means...
Guide hubWhen Does Workers' Comp Start Paying in Texas?
Texas workers' comp income benefits begin after a one-week waiting period.
ReadBench Trial vs Jury Trial in a Texas Injury Case
In a bench trial the judge decides the facts and the law, while in a jury trial the jurors decide the disputed facts and the judge applies the law.
ReadStructured Settlements in Texas: Payments and Sales
A structured settlement resolves an injury claim with a series of future payments, such as monthly...
ReadCedar Park Wrongful Death Lawyer
Texas injury representation for wrongful death.
Practice area
Frequently asked questions
A benefit review conference is an informal meeting where a benefit review officer from the Texas Division of Workers' Compensation helps the injured employee and the insurance carrier try to settle a disputed claim. The officer cannot take testimony or make a formal record. Unresolved issues are listed in a report and move on to a contested case hearing or, if both sides agree, to arbitration.
Texas law does not require one. Labor Code Section 410.006 lets a claimant be represented by an attorney or assisted by a person of the claimant's choice who does not work for an attorney or receive a fee. The Texas Department of Insurance also points unrepresented employees to the Office of Injured Employee Counsel for free ombudsman help. An agreement signed at the conference binds a represented claimant to the same extent as the carrier.
A contested case hearing is the formal stage after a benefit review conference that did not resolve every issue. An administrative law judge swears witnesses, takes testimony, accepts documents and issues a written decision with findings of fact, conclusions of law and any benefits due. The Division must set it for a date no later than 60 days after the conference, and issues not raised at the conference generally cannot be added.
A party has 15 days after receiving the administrative law judge's decision to file a written request for appeal with the appeals panel, serving a copy on the other party the same day. Saturdays, Sundays and listed state holidays are not counted. The Texas Department of Insurance states that late appeals are not considered, and without a timely appeal the hearing decision becomes final.
Yes, but only after the benefit review conference, the contested case hearing and the appeals panel. Suit must be filed within 45 days after the Division mailed the final appeals panel decision. For compensability and income benefit issues, the court or jury decides the disputed issues again, the appealing party must prove its case by a preponderance of the evidence, and jurors are told what the appeals panel decided.
The Valentine Law Firm handles Texas personal injury cases. This guide is general information about Texas law, not legal advice.
Was someone hurt in a crash?
If a collision or injury is behind your question, The Valentine Law Firm offers a free consultation on where you stand.
Contingency fee. You pay nothing unless we win.