Bench Trial vs Jury Trial: How a Texas Injury Case Is Decided

In a bench trial the judge decides the facts and the law, while in a jury trial the jurors decide the disputed facts and the judge applies the law. A Texas civil case goes to a jury only if a party requests one in writing and pays the jury fee or swears it cannot pay. This guide covers the right, the request and how each trial ends.

  • 138Google reviews
  • 3Attorneys on your case
  • 2 yrsTexas filing deadline
  • No feeUnless we win

Who decides the facts in each kind of trial

Questions of fact ask what happened, such as whether a driver ran a red light. Questions of law ask what rules apply. In a bench trial, one judge answers both. In a jury trial, the jurors answer the fact questions and the judge handles the law.

A Texas civil jury answers written questions. Rule 277 of the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure calls for broad-form questions whenever feasible, and, when the jury apportions the loss, a question on each culpable person's percentage of negligence or causation, which is how shared fault under Texas comparative negligence reaches a verdict. Rule 290 says a special verdict is conclusive between the parties as to the facts found, and Rule 300 has the court render judgment on it.

In a bench trial there is no charge and no verdict; the judge weighs the evidence and signs the judgment. Other court terms are explained in the Texas legal guides.

Where the right to a civil jury comes from in Texas

Article I, Section 15 of the Texas Constitution states that the right of trial by jury shall remain inviolate. The same section directs the Legislature to pass laws needed to regulate that right and to maintain its purity and efficiency.

Article V, Section 10 deals with civil cases in the district courts. It gives the plaintiff or defendant the right of trial by jury upon application made in open court, but it adds a condition: no jury is to be seated in any civil case unless a party demands one and pays a jury fee, in the amount and with the exceptions the Legislature sets. The right is not automatic; a party has to claim it.

How a party gets a jury: the written request and the fee

Under Rule 216, no jury trial is held in a civil suit unless a written request is filed with the clerk a reasonable time before the date set for trial on the non-jury docket, and not less than 30 days in advance. The jury fee must be deposited within the same time. Unless other law provides otherwise, the rule sets it at ten dollars in district court and five dollars in county court, and its comment notes that other law may add fees. Under Rule 217, a party who cannot pay may file an affidavit of inability instead, and the case goes on the jury docket that Rule 218 has the clerk keep.

A demand by one side protects both. Rule 220 says a party who paid the jury fee cannot withdraw the case from the jury docket over the objection of the opposing parties, and that a party who fails to appear for trial waives the right to a jury. The request comes after filing a personal injury lawsuit, and the questioning and striking of jurors that follow are covered in the guide to jury selection in Texas.

How many jurors sit on a Texas civil jury

Government Code Section 62.201 provides that a district court jury is composed of 12 people, although the parties may agree to try a particular case with fewer. Section 62.301 sets the jury in county courts and justice courts at six, except as the constitution or other law provides. Rule 234 uses the same numbers when the clerk calls the jury.

A Texas civil verdict does not always have to be unanimous. How many jurors must agree, and what happens when they cannot, is explained in the guide to jury deliberations, hung juries and mistrials.

What happens in a bench trial

Rule 262 says the rules that govern a jury trial also govern a trial by the court as far as they apply. The parties still state their claims and defenses, call witnesses and cross-examine them, broadly in the order Rule 265 sets for a jury trial. What drops out are the steps that exist only for jurors: the panel, voir dire, the written charge, argument addressed to the jury under Rule 269, and deliberations.

Texas also allows a third route that involves no live testimony. Under Rule 263, the parties may submit the dispute to the court on an agreed statement of facts filed with the clerk, and the court renders judgment on it as in other cases.

Findings of fact and conclusions of law under Rules 296 to 299a

Under Rule 296, in any case tried without a jury in district or county court, any party may file a request for findings of fact and conclusions of law within 20 days after the judgment is signed. Rule 297 gives the court 20 days after a timely request to send them. If it does not, the requesting party must file a notice of past due findings within 30 days after the original request, which extends the court's time to 40 days from that request. Under Rule 298, any party may then ask for specified additional or amended findings within 10 days, and the court has 10 days to respond.

Rule 299 makes the findings the basis of the judgment on every claim and defense they cover. If the judge found at least one element of a claim or defense, omitted elements that nobody requested and the evidence supports are presumed in favor of the judgment. Rule 299a requires findings of fact to be in a document separate from the judgment.

How the two paths differ after trial

After a jury trial, Rule 301 lets the judge, on motion and notice, render judgment notwithstanding the verdict if a directed verdict would have been proper, or disregard a jury finding that has no support in the evidence. In a bench trial there is no verdict to set aside, because the judge's own findings and judgment are the decision.

Under Rule 324, a point in a motion for new trial is generally not required to raise a complaint on appeal, in jury or nonjury cases. It is required for listed complaints, such as newly discovered evidence, or a claim that the evidence is factually insufficient to support a jury finding or that the damages the jury found are inadequate or excessive.

Practical trade-offs between a judge and a jury

A jury trial adds jury selection, a written charge and deliberations, and it requires a timely demand and fee. A jury answers questions in a verdict, while a judge in a bench trial can be required to explain the decision in written findings. A bench trial turns on how one person weighs the evidence, while a jury verdict needs the agreement of a group, and Rule 292(b) allows exemplary damages only if the jury is unanimous on both liability for them and their amount.

No rule says either kind of fact-finder favors one side, and the choice depends on the facts of each case. Many claims are resolved in negotiation or mediation without any trial, as the share of personal injury cases that go to trial shows. When a trial is needed, its format is part of the planning in any Texas personal injury claim.

Summary

The Texas Constitution protects the right of trial by jury, but no civil jury is seated unless a party demands one and pays a jury fee. Under Rule 216, the written request and fee are due not less than 30 days before the trial setting. Without a timely demand, the judge decides the case, and any party can ask for written findings of fact and conclusions of law under Rules 296 to 299a. A district court jury generally has 12 members and a county court jury generally has 6.

Bench trial vs jury trial in a Texas civil case
IssueJury trialBench trial
Who decides disputed factsThe jurors, through answers to the court's chargeThe judge
How a case gets this formatWritten request and fee at least 30 days before trial (Rule 216)No demand is needed
Size of the fact-finder12 in district court, 6 in county court (Government Code Sections 62.201 and 62.301)One judge
Steps unique to the formatVoir dire, the charge, jury argument, deliberationsOptional findings of fact and conclusions of law (Rules 296 to 299a)
How the decision is recordedA verdict, signed by the presiding juror (Rule 290)A judgment, with findings in a separate document if requested (Rule 299a)
Motion for new trial before appealRequired for some complaints about jury findings and damages (Rule 324(b))Generally not required, with listed exceptions such as newly discovered evidence (Rule 324)

Frequently asked questions

In a bench trial, the judge decides both the facts and the law and signs the judgment. In a jury trial, jurors decide the disputed facts by answering written questions in the court's charge, and the judge applies the law to those answers. A Texas civil case is tried to a jury only if a party files a written request and, on time, pays the jury fee or files an affidavit of inability to pay.

Yes. Article I, Section 15 of the Texas Constitution says the right of trial by jury shall remain inviolate, and Article V, Section 10 gives parties in district court the right to a jury. The same section says no civil jury is seated unless a party demands one and pays a jury fee, so the right has to be claimed.

Under Rule 216 of the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure, a party files a written request for a jury trial with the court clerk a reasonable time before the non-jury trial setting, and not less than 30 days in advance. The jury fee is deposited within the same time. A party who cannot pay may file an affidavit of inability under Rule 217.

A trial with no jury is called a bench trial or a trial by the court. The judge hears the evidence, decides the facts and signs the judgment. In a Texas civil case, this is what happens when no party makes a timely jury demand. The parties can also submit a case to the judge on an agreed statement of facts under Rule 263.

They are the judge's written explanation of a decision after a bench trial. In Texas, any party may request them within 20 days after the judgment is signed under Rule 296, and the court must send them within 20 days of a timely request under Rule 297. The findings of fact must be in a document separate from the judgment, and they form the basis of the judgment.

The Valentine Law Firm handles Texas personal injury cases. This guide is general information about Texas law, not legal advice.

Was someone hurt in a crash?

If a collision or injury is behind your question, The Valentine Law Firm offers a free consultation on where you stand.

Contingency fee. You pay nothing unless we win.

Call Now Free Consultation