Texas Nonsubscriber Employers: What Injured Workers Can Do
A Texas non subscriber is an employer that has chosen not to carry workers compensation insurance. An employee hurt on the job cannot claim state comp benefits from that employer, but can sue it for negligence, and the employer loses three common-law defenses. This guide covers what must be proven, barred defenses, waivers, benefit plans, arbitration and the deadline.
- 138Google reviews
- 3Attorneys on your case
- 2 yrsTexas filing deadline
- No feeUnless we win
What a nonsubscriber is under Texas law
Most private employers in Texas can choose whether to carry workers compensation insurance. Labor Code Section 406.002 says that, except for public employers and as otherwise provided by law, an employer may elect to obtain coverage. An employer that elects not to is called a nonsubscriber, or non-subscriber.
Section 406.003 recognizes two ways to obtain coverage: through a licensed insurance company or through self-insurance as the statute allows. The Department's Division of Workers' Compensation states that accident, health or disability policies bought as a cheaper alternative are not substitutes for workers compensation coverage. An employer with only that kind of policy is still a nonsubscriber.
The difference matters because of what each system offers. A covered employee receives the workers compensation benefits set by Texas law from the insurance carrier, and under Section 408.001 those benefits are the exclusive remedy against the employer. A nonsubscriber's employee has no comp claim against the employer but keeps the right to sue it. More explainers like this one are in the Legal Guides hub.
How to find out whether an employer has coverage
Texas law puts the burden of disclosure on the employer. Section 406.005 requires an employer to tell each new employee at the time of hire whether it has coverage and to post a notice in conspicuous places at the workplace. When coverage is obtained, terminated or canceled, the employer must tell each employee no later than the 15th day after the change takes effect.
A nonsubscriber must also report its choice to the state. Section 406.004 requires an employer that does not obtain coverage to notify the Division in writing. The Division publishes a list of registered non-subscribers and offers an online coverage lookup for insured employers.
When the answer is still unclear, the Division's coverage verification page tells workers to email its coverage verification desk with the employer's name, the employer's physical address and the date of injury. The page says a reply comes within one business day.
What an injured worker must prove
A nonsubscriber claim is a negligence lawsuit, not a benefits claim. Section 406.033(d) says the plaintiff must prove negligence of the employer, or of an agent or servant of the employer acting within the general scope of that person's employment. The worker needs evidence of the four elements of negligence.
The Supreme Court of Texas underlined this point in Austin v. Kroger Texas, L.P., 465 S.W.3d 193 (2015). An employee slipped while mopping a spill he knew about, and the court held that the loss of the employer's defenses does not remove the employee's burden, in a premises liability claim, of proving that the employer owed him a duty. In most cases that duty does not extend to hazards that are open and obvious or already known to the employee, subject to two limited exceptions.
The employee also claimed that the employer failed to provide equipment needed to do the job safely, and the court said that kind of claim does not require negligent activity by the employer at the moment of the injury. Hazard cases of this type overlap with slip and fall claims at work.
The defenses a nonsubscriber loses
Section 406.033(a) removes three defenses in a suit by an employee who is not covered by workers compensation insurance. The employer may not argue that the employee was guilty of contributory negligence, that the employee assumed the risk of injury or death, or that the injury or death was caused by the negligence of a fellow employee.
In Kroger Co. v. Keng, 23 S.W.3d 347 (2000), the Supreme Court of Texas held that a nonsubscribing employer is not entitled to a jury question on its employee's comparative responsibility. In most other injury cases, Texas comparative negligence rules let a defendant reduce or defeat a claim by pointing to the injured person's share of fault. Against a nonsubscriber, the jury is not asked to divide fault between employer and employee.
The statute expressly preserves two defenses. Under Section 406.033(c), the employer may defend the case on the ground that the injury was caused by an act of the employee intended to bring about the injury, or while the employee was in a state of intoxication.
Waivers before and after an injury
An employer cannot contract its way out of this liability in advance. Section 406.033(e) says the cause of action may not be waived by an employee before the injury or death, and any agreement to do so is void and unenforceable.
A waiver signed after the injury is valid only if four conditions in Section 406.033(f) are met. The employee must enter into it voluntarily and with knowledge of its effect, it cannot be signed earlier than the 10th business day after the initial report of injury, the employee must first receive a medical evaluation from a nonemergency care doctor, and it must be in a writing that specifically states the true intent of the parties.
Section 406.033(g) adds that the waiver provisions must be conspicuous and appear on the face of the agreement, in type larger than the body text or in contrasting colors.
Occupational benefit plans and arbitration agreements
Some nonsubscribers instead buy accident, health or disability policies or use employer indemnification agreements. The Division says these alternatives typically have specific limits on medical benefits and shorter payment periods than Texas workers compensation law provides. It also notes that an employer with an alternative plan can still be sued by an injured employee and still loses the common law defenses.
A plan may come with an arbitration agreement. In In re Golden Peanut Co., 298 S.W.3d 629 (2009), a worker killed on the job had been a party to an employee injury benefit plan with an attached agreement to arbitrate injury and death claims. The Supreme Court of Texas held that Section 406.033(e) did not invalidate the agreement, because agreeing to arbitrate is not a waiver of the claim but an agreement to try it in a specific forum.
The court also held that the worker's family members were bound by his agreement in their wrongful death claims. Arbitration changes where the claim is decided, not whether it exists. Families in that position can read more on the wrongful death lawyer page.
Construction work, public projects and third parties
Construction is one area where the choice is narrower. Section 406.096 requires a governmental entity that enters into a building or construction contract to make the contractor certify in writing that it provides workers compensation coverage for each employee on the public project.
On private projects a contractor may be a nonsubscriber. A worker's claim against the direct employer follows the rules above, while a claim against another company on the site follows different rules that depend on that company's role. The construction accident lawyer page explains how those claims fit together.
The two-year deadline to sue
A nonsubscriber claim is a personal injury suit, so the general deadline applies. Civil Practice and Remedies Code Section 16.003(a) requires a person to bring suit for personal injury not later than two years after the day the cause of action accrues. Under Section 16.003(b), a suit for an injury resulting in death must also be brought within two years, and that claim accrues on the death of the injured person. The guide to the Texas statute of limitations covers how the deadline is counted.
Summary
Most private employers in Texas can choose whether to carry workers compensation insurance, and one that goes without is a nonsubscriber. Under Labor Code Section 406.033, its injured employee may sue for negligence, and the employer cannot rely on the worker's own negligence, assumption of the risk or a coworker's negligence. The worker must still prove that the employer or its agent was negligent. Waivers signed before an injury are void, while an arbitration agreement can still move the case out of court. A personal injury suit generally must be filed within two years under Section 16.003.
| Question | Employer with coverage | Nonsubscriber |
|---|---|---|
| Claim against the employer | Workers compensation benefits; exclusive remedy under Section 408.001 | Negligence lawsuit under Section 406.033 |
| Must the worker prove negligence? | No lawsuit against the employer; benefits are set by state law | Yes, negligence of the employer or its agent |
| Can the employer blame the worker's negligence? | Not applicable to a benefits claim | No, barred by Section 406.033(a) |
| Defenses the employer keeps | Not applicable to a benefits claim | Intentional self-injury and intoxication |
| Waiver signed before injury | Not applicable | Void and unenforceable |
| Where the claim is decided | Division of Workers' Compensation process | Court, or arbitration if a valid agreement applies |
| Deadline | Comp notice and claim deadlines | Two years to sue under Section 16.003 |
Keep reading
Legal Guides
The core legal ideas behind a Texas injury claim, in plain language: what negligence means...
Guide hubWhen Does Workers' Comp Start Paying in Texas?
Texas workers' comp income benefits begin after a one-week waiting period.
ReadTexas Tort Claims Act: Notice, Caps and Who Can Sue
The Texas Tort Claims Act is the state law that decides when an injured person can sue a governmental unit.
ReadAttractive Nuisance in Texas: Child Trespasser Rule
The attractive nuisance doctrine in Texas can make a property owner liable when a highly dangerous...
ReadCedar Park Wrongful Death Lawyer
Texas injury representation for wrongful death.
Practice area
Frequently asked questions
A non-subscriber is a Texas employer that has chosen not to carry workers compensation insurance. Labor Code Section 406.002 makes coverage elective for most private employers. An employee of a non-subscriber has no state comp claim against the employer but may sue the employer for negligence.
Yes. Section 406.033 of the Labor Code allows an employee who is not covered by workers compensation insurance to sue the employer for damages for a work injury. The employee must prove that the employer, or an agent acting within the scope of employment, was negligent. The employer cannot defend by pointing to the employee's own negligence, assumption of the risk or a coworker's negligence.
Section 406.005 requires a Texas employer to tell new hires whether it has coverage and to post a notice at the workplace. The Division of Workers' Compensation also publishes a list of registered non-subscribers and an online lookup for insured employers. A worker who still cannot tell can email the Division's coverage verification desk with the employer's name, physical address and the date of injury.
No. Section 406.033(e) says an employee cannot waive the claim before the injury or death, and any agreement to do so is void and unenforceable. A waiver signed after the injury is valid only if the employee signs voluntarily, at least 10 business days after the initial injury report, after an evaluation by a nonemergency care doctor, and in a conspicuous written agreement.
Generally two years. Civil Practice and Remedies Code Section 16.003(a) requires a personal injury suit to be brought not later than two years after the cause of action accrues. When the injury results in death, Section 16.003(b) also allows two years, counted from the date of death.
The Valentine Law Firm handles Texas personal injury cases. This guide is general information about Texas law, not legal advice.
Was someone hurt in a crash?
If a collision or injury is behind your question, The Valentine Law Firm offers a free consultation on where you stand.
Contingency fee. You pay nothing unless we win.