Attractive Nuisance in Texas: When Property Owners Are Liable for Injuries to Trespassing Children
The attractive nuisance doctrine in Texas can make a property owner liable when a highly dangerous artificial condition on the land injures a trespassing child who was too young to recognize the risk. It is an exception to the rule that owners owe trespassers almost no duty. This guide covers the five conditions, the age question, common examples and pool enclosure rules.
- 138Google reviews
- 3Attorneys on your case
- 2 yrsTexas filing deadline
- No feeUnless we win
The starting point: owners owe trespassers very little
Section 75.007 of the Civil Practice and Remedies Code defines a trespasser as a person who enters the land of another without any legal right, express or implied. Under Section 75.007(b), an owner, lessee or occupant owes a trespasser no duty of care except a duty to refrain from injuring the trespasser wilfully, wantonly or through gross negligence, a standard explained in the guide to gross negligence and ordinary negligence.
Subsection (c) makes an exception for children. Despite the trespasser rule, an owner may be liable for injury to a child caused by a highly dangerous artificial condition on the land. That is the attractive nuisance doctrine, one of the concepts collected in the Legal Guides hub.
The five conditions in Section 75.007(c)
The statute joins five conditions with the word "and", so every one must be shown. First, the owner knew or reasonably should have known that children were likely to trespass where the condition exists. Second, the owner knew or reasonably should have known of the condition, and realized or should have realized it involved an unreasonable risk of death or serious bodily harm to those children.
Third, the child, because of youth, did not discover the condition or realize the risk of meddling with it or coming within the area it made dangerous. Fourth, the usefulness of the condition to the owner and the burden of eliminating the danger were slight compared with the risk to the child. Fifth, the owner failed to use reasonable care to eliminate the danger or otherwise protect the child.
The condition must be a highly dangerous artificial condition on the land. Section 75.007(e) adds that the section does not create or increase the liability of any person.
How the Supreme Court of Texas explains the doctrine
The leading modern case is Texas Utilities Electric Co. v. Timmons, 947 S.W.2d 191 (Tex. 1997). The Supreme Court of Texas traced the doctrine to cases about children hurt on railroad turntables.
The older theory was that an owner who keeps an unusually alluring device on the land impliedly invites young children onto it. Timmons says Texas adopted the Restatement of Torts version of the doctrine in 1948, and it quotes the five-part test from section 339 of the Restatement (Second) of Torts, which the statute closely tracks.
When the doctrine applies, the owner owes a trespassing child the duty owed to an invitee: ordinary care to reduce or eliminate an unreasonable risk from a condition the owner knows or reasonably should know about. The case then proceeds on the usual elements of negligence.
The child's age and understanding
Section 75.007 sets no cutoff age, apart from the rule in Section 75.003(b) for trespassers over 16 on agricultural land. The court declined to impose one, while quoting the Restatement's observation that in the great majority of cases applying the doctrine the child was not more than twelve. The test is whether the child is still too young to appreciate the danger.
In Timmons a 14-year-old climbed a 90-foot electric transmission tower and was killed when electricity arced from a high-voltage line. The tower had a barbed wire barricade and a warning sign, and friends had repeatedly told him he could be electrocuted. His mother argued that he did not know electricity could arc and was less mature than others his age.
The court held, as a matter of law, that the doctrine did not apply, because a child aware of the general danger of high-voltage lines cannot rely on not knowing exactly how harm would occur. It distinguished two older cases involving boys of 14 and 15, where towers had spike ladders and no signs or guards, noting it had earlier called them exceptional cases.
Pools, trampolines and machinery as examples
The statute does not list attractive nuisances. Every object is measured against the five conditions, and the examples below illustrate that analysis rather than report rulings.
A swimming pool is artificial and can drown a small child, so disputes turn on whether the owner should have expected neighborhood children, whether the child was too young to understand deep water, and whether a fence or locked gate was a slight burden. Machinery left where children play raises the same questions.
A backyard trampoline fits less neatly, because a child invited to use it is not a trespasser. A child with permission is not a trespasser, so the visitor categories in Texas slip and fall law apply instead. Commercial parks are covered in trampoline park injury claims.
Pool enclosure rules for apartments and associations
Health and Safety Code Chapter 757 sets written pool enclosure standards, but under Section 757.002 it applies only to pools owned, controlled or maintained by the owner of a multiunit rental complex or by a property owners association. A single-family home outside a condominium project is not a multiunit rental complex.
Where it applies, Section 757.003 requires the pool yard to be completely enclosed by a barrier at least 48 inches high, measured on the side away from the pool. Section 757.004 requires self-closing, self-latching gates that open outward, and Section 757.009 requires inspection of enclosures, gates and latches no less than once every 31 days.
Section 757.012 lets a tenant, association member or any other person sue for actual damages caused by a failure to comply. Pool cases are one category in the overview of types of premises liability claims.
Limits on the doctrine
Under Section 75.003(b), attractive nuisance may not be the basis for liability of an owner, lessee or occupant of agricultural land for injury to a trespasser over the age of 16 years. Section 75.0025 limits the doctrine for certain claims about land used as a community garden.
Government land is largely outside the doctrine. Chapter 101, the Texas Tort Claims Act, waives immunity only to the extent of the liability it creates, and Section 101.059 says the chapter does not apply to a claim based on the theory of attractive nuisance.
Warnings and barriers also count. In Timmons the sign, barbed wire and spoken warnings supported the court's holding that the boy realized the risk. Separately, barriers and warnings bear on the fifth condition, whether the owner failed to use reasonable care.
How the doctrine fits into a premises liability case
Attractive nuisance establishes the duty, and the rest of a premises liability claim still has to be proved. Useful proof includes photographs of the condition, fences and signs, earlier complaints about children on the property, and testimony about what the child understood, as described in the guide to evidence in a premises liability claim.
Section 16.001 treats a person younger than 18 as under a legal disability, and if the child was under 18 when the child's own claim arose, the time of the disability is not included in the limitations period. General deadlines are covered in the Texas statute of limitations guide. When a child dies, the family brings a claim for wrongful death of a child, with attractive nuisance supplying the duty.
Summary
Texas owners owe a trespasser only a duty not to cause injury wilfully, wantonly or through gross negligence, but Section 75.007(c) keeps an exception for children hurt by a highly dangerous artificial condition. All five statutory conditions must be met, including that the child, because of youth, failed to realize the risk. The Supreme Court of Texas sets no fixed age and asks whether the child was still too young to appreciate the danger.
| Condition | Question it raises in practice |
|---|---|
| 1. Owner knew or should have known children were likely to trespass there | Were children seen there before, or is the spot near homes, a school or a park? |
| 2. Owner knew or should have known the condition involved an unreasonable risk of death or serious bodily harm to children | Did the owner know of the hazard, and should the owner have seen the danger to children? |
| 3. Because of youth, the child did not discover the condition or realize the risk | How old was the child, what warnings were given, and what did the child understand? |
| 4. The condition's usefulness and the cost of removing the danger were slight compared with the risk | Would a fence, lock, cover or removal have been cheap relative to the harm? |
| 5. Owner failed to use reasonable care to eliminate the danger or protect the child | What barriers, signs or supervision were in place on the day of the injury? |
Keep reading
Legal Guides
The core legal ideas behind a Texas injury claim, in plain language: what negligence means...
Guide hubGross Negligence vs Ordinary Negligence in Texas
Ordinary negligence is carelessness, like a driver who was not paying attention.
ReadStructured Settlements in Texas: Payments and Sales
A structured settlement resolves an injury claim with a series of future payments, such as monthly...
ReadJury Duty in Texas: Pay, Exemptions and Penalties
Texas pays jurors: a county must pay a person who reports for jury duty at least 20 dollars...
ReadCedar Park Wrongful Death Lawyer
Texas injury representation for wrongful death.
Practice area
Frequently asked questions
It is an exception to the rule that a Texas property owner owes a trespasser no duty of ordinary care. Under Section 75.007(c) of the Civil Practice and Remedies Code, an owner, lessee or occupant may be liable for injury to a child caused by a highly dangerous artificial condition if five conditions are met, including that the child, because of youth, did not realize the risk.
Yes. The doctrine began as case law, and Section 75.007(c) of the Civil Practice and Remedies Code now lists its five conditions. Section 75.003(b) bars its use against owners of agricultural land for trespassers over the age of 16 years, and Section 101.059 says the Texas Tort Claims Act does not apply to a claim based on attractive nuisance.
There is no fixed age. In the Timmons case, the Supreme Court of Texas declined to set an age limit and asked whether the child was still too young to appreciate the danger. It noted that in most cases applying the doctrine the child was not more than twelve, and held that a warned 14-year-old who climbed an electric tower was not covered.
Not automatically. The statute names no objects. A pool is an artificial condition, so the outcome depends on whether the owner should have expected children, whether the child was too young to understand the danger, and whether reasonable steps such as a fence or locked gate were taken. Apartment and association pools must also meet Health and Safety Code Chapter 757 enclosure rules.
A sign helps but does not settle the question. In Timmons, a warning sign, a barbed wire barricade and repeated spoken warnings supported the ruling that a 14-year-old realized the risk. A sign means little to a child too young to read it, and the statute asks whether the owner used reasonable care to eliminate the danger or protect the child.
The Valentine Law Firm handles Texas personal injury cases. This guide is general information about Texas law, not legal advice.
Was someone hurt in a crash?
If a collision or injury is behind your question, The Valentine Law Firm offers a free consultation on where you stand.
Contingency fee. You pay nothing unless we win.