What Does Dismissed With Prejudice Mean in Texas?
When a Texas court dismisses a lawsuit with prejudice, the claim is over for good. The Supreme Court of Texas treats that kind of dismissal as a final determination on the merits, so the same claim generally cannot be filed again. A dismissal without prejudice leaves the door open, but the deadline to sue keeps running. This guide explains both, plus nonsuits and dismissals for want of prosecution.
- 138Google reviews
- 3Attorneys on your case
- 2 yrsTexas filing deadline
- No feeUnless we win
What dismissed with prejudice means
A dismissal is a court order that ends a lawsuit, or one claim in it, without a verdict on that claim. The words that follow matter most. In Mossler v. Shields, 818 S.W.2d 752 (Tex. 1991), the Supreme Court of Texas said it is well established that a dismissal with prejudice functions as a final determination on the merits.
That rule applied even though the dismissal in Mossler was a sanction for discovery abuse under Rule 215, not a ruling after trial. The court held that the dismissal stood as a final judgment on the merits and barred the later claim. For an injured person, a dismissal with prejudice of a negligence claim has the same practical effect as losing that claim at trial.
Why a second lawsuit is barred
The doctrine that stops a refiled suit is res judicata. In Amstadt v. U.S. Brass Corp. (Tex. 1996), the Supreme Court of Texas listed its elements: a prior final judgment on the merits by a court of competent jurisdiction, identity of parties or those in privity with them, and a second action based on the same claims as were raised or could have been raised in the first action.
The last element reaches further than many people expect. If a driver's negligence claim from a crash is dismissed with prejudice, a new suit against the same driver over the same crash can be barred even if it adds a different legal theory, because that theory could have been raised the first time. It does not matter that no jury ever weighed the elements of negligence.
Dismissed without prejudice, and the deadline that keeps running
A dismissal without prejudice does not decide who was right, so the claim can usually be filed again. The catch is time. Civil Practice and Remedies Code Section 16.003 requires a personal injury suit to be brought not later than two years after the day the cause of action accrues, and a dismissal does not reset that clock. In Rizk v. Mayad (Tex. 1980), the court noted that a litigant who refiles may face limitations problems.
Section 16.064 gives limited relief. If a case is dismissed because the first court lacked jurisdiction, and the same action is filed in a proper court not later than the 60th day after the dismissal becomes final, the time in between does not count against limitations. It does not apply if the first filing was made with intentional disregard of proper jurisdiction. See the Texas statute of limitations for other deadlines.
Nonsuit: when the plaintiff dismisses the case
Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 162 lets a plaintiff dismiss or take a nonsuit at any time before the plaintiff has introduced all of his evidence other than rebuttal evidence. A plaintiff might do this to fix a problem with the parties or the court, or because the claim has settled. Notice goes to every party that has answered or been served.
A nonsuit has limits. It does not prejudice the other side's right to be heard on a pending claim for affirmative relief, such as a counterclaim, and it does not affect pending motions for sanctions, attorney's fees or other costs. Unless the court orders otherwise, the clerk may tax court costs against the dismissing party. Anyone weighing a nonsuit should first check how much time remains under Section 16.003.
Dismissed for want of prosecution
Rule 165a lets a court dismiss a case for want of prosecution, often called a DWOP, in two main situations. The first is when a party seeking affirmative relief fails to appear for a hearing or trial after notice; the rule directs the court to dismiss unless there is good cause to keep the case on the docket. The second is a case not disposed of within the time standards set by the Supreme Court of Texas, which may be placed on a dismissal docket.
A DWOP is aimed at stalled cases, not at the merits. Rizk v. Mayad explains that a litigant may refile an action dismissed for want of prosecution because the merits remain undecided. Refiling still has to happen within the limitations period, which is why a DWOP late in a case can be as serious as a loss. A case that has gone quiet is worth comparing against how long an injury case takes.
Getting a dismissed case reinstated
Rule 165a(3) provides a way back. A motion to reinstate must state its grounds, be sworn to (verified) by the movant or the attorney, and be filed within 30 days after the order of dismissal is signed, or within the period provided by Rule 306a. The court shall reinstate the case if it finds after a hearing that the failure was not intentional or the result of conscious indifference, but was due to accident or mistake or has otherwise been reasonably explained.
The wording of the order matters too. In El Paso Pipe & Supply Co. v. Mountain States Leasing (Tex. 1981), a trial court erroneously dismissed a case for want of prosecution with prejudice. The Supreme Court of Texas held the order still bound the plaintiff because it was not challenged by appeal or bill of review, so a mistaken label has to be attacked directly, not ignored.
Dismissals the defense can ask for
Rule 91a lets a party move to dismiss a cause of action that has no basis in law or fact. The motion must be filed within 60 days after the first pleading containing the challenged claim is served, and the court must rule within 45 days after it is filed. The court may not consider evidence and decides the motion on the pleading, and it may award the prevailing party costs and reasonable attorney's fees.
Health care claims carry a stricter trap. Section 74.351 requires the claimant to serve an expert report on each physician or health care provider not later than the 120th day after that defendant's original answer is filed. If it is not served, the court, on the defendant's motion, shall award that defendant reasonable attorney's fees and costs and dismiss the claim with prejudice to refiling. A deficient report may get one 30-day extension. See medical malpractice vs wrongful death.
Agreed dismissals after a settlement
Not every dismissal with prejudice is bad news. When an injury lawsuit settles, the parties commonly ask the court to sign an agreed order dismissing the case with prejudice, so the defendant knows the claim cannot return. In that setting the order reflects the deal rather than a loss, and the money is paid under the settlement agreement.
Because the order is final, the settlement terms need to be right before anyone signs. That includes the amount, the parties being released, and how liens and medical bills will be paid, since the dismissal will not leave room to reopen those points later. Many cases reach that stage through mediation in personal injury cases, and the steps before it are covered in how to file a personal injury lawsuit.
Summary
A dismissal with prejudice ends a claim permanently because Texas treats it as a final determination on the merits, and res judicata then bars a second suit on the same claims. A dismissal without prejudice, including most dismissals for want of prosecution, leaves the merits undecided, but any refiled suit still has to beat the two-year deadline in Section 16.003. A case dismissed for want of prosecution can be reinstated on a verified motion filed within 30 days after the order is signed. In health care claims, missing the expert report deadline leads to a mandatory dismissal with prejudice and a fee award.
| Type | Source | What it means for the claim |
|---|---|---|
| Dismissal with prejudice | Mossler v. Shields (1991) | Final determination on the merits; res judicata bars refiling the same claims |
| Dismissal without prejudice | CPRC 16.003 | Can usually be refiled, but only within the two-year limitations period |
| Nonsuit by the plaintiff | TRCP 162 | Other side's pending claims for affirmative relief and fee or sanctions motions survive |
| Dismissal for want of prosecution | TRCP 165a; Rizk v. Mayad (1980) | Merits undecided; verified reinstatement motion due within 30 days after the order is signed |
| Dismissal for lack of jurisdiction | CPRC 16.064 | Limitations suspended if refiled in a proper court within 60 days after the dismissal is final |
| Baseless cause of action | TRCP 91a | Decided on the pleadings; court may award costs and attorney's fees |
| Missed expert report (health care claim) | CPRC 74.351(b) | Dismissal with prejudice plus the defendant's attorney's fees and costs |
Keep reading
Legal Guides
The core legal ideas behind a Texas injury claim, in plain language: what negligence means...
Guide hubHung Jury, Deliberations and Mistrials in Texas
A hung jury is a jury that cannot reach the agreement the law requires, and it ends the trial in a mistrial.
ReadThe Four Elements of Negligence in Texas
To hold someone responsible for an injury in Texas, you have to prove four things: that they owed you...
ReadWhat Is a De Novo Hearing in Texas?
A de novo hearing is a fresh hearing in which a court decides the issues itself, without being bound by an earlier ruling.
ReadCedar Park Wrongful Death Lawyer
Texas injury representation for wrongful death.
Practice area
Frequently asked questions
It means the court has ended the claim permanently. The Supreme Court of Texas said in Mossler v. Shields that a dismissal with prejudice functions as a final determination on the merits, even when no trial took place. Res judicata then bars a new suit between the same parties on the same claims, including claims that could have been raised in the first case.
Not by filing it again. The order itself has to be challenged directly while that is still possible. In El Paso Pipe & Supply Co. v. Mountain States Leasing, the Supreme Court of Texas held that even an erroneous with-prejudice dismissal bound the plaintiff because it was not attacked by appeal or bill of review. Once the time for those challenges passes, the dismissal is generally final.
It means the court dismissed the case for lack of activity rather than on the merits. Under Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 165a, this can happen when a party seeking relief fails to appear for a hearing or trial after notice, or when a case is not disposed of within the Supreme Court's time standards. A verified motion to reinstate must be filed within 30 days after the dismissal order is signed.
A dismissal with prejudice is treated as a final judgment on the merits, so the claim cannot be brought again. A dismissal without prejudice leaves the merits undecided, so the claim can usually be refiled. The time limit does not pause, though, so a refiled personal injury suit generally still has to meet the two-year deadline in Civil Practice and Remedies Code Section 16.003.
It depends on the type of dismissal and the calendar. A claim dismissed with prejudice cannot be refiled. A claim dismissed without prejudice or for want of prosecution usually can be, but only within the two-year limitations period. If the first court lacked jurisdiction, Section 16.064 suspends limitations when the case is refiled in a proper court within 60 days after the dismissal becomes final.
The Valentine Law Firm handles Texas personal injury cases. This guide is general information about Texas law, not legal advice.
Was someone hurt in a crash?
If a collision or injury is behind your question, The Valentine Law Firm offers a free consultation on where you stand.
Contingency fee. You pay nothing unless we win.