What Is a De Novo Hearing in Texas?

A de novo hearing is a fresh hearing in which a court decides the issues itself, without being bound by an earlier ruling. In Texas civil cases, the term appears in appeals from justice court, in reviews of associate judge decisions, in workers' compensation suits and in appellate review of legal questions. This guide explains each setting, its deadline and its source.

  • 138Google reviews
  • 3Attorneys on your case
  • 2 yrsTexas filing deadline
  • No feeUnless we win

What de novo means

De novo is Latin for anew, or from the beginning. When a court hears something de novo, it decides the matter itself rather than deferring to what an earlier judge or agency concluded. The term is used in two ways: a trial de novo rehears the whole case, while de novo review decides a legal question afresh from the existing record.

Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 506.3 gives the term a concrete meaning: a trial de novo is a new trial in which the entire case is presented as if there had been no previous trial. Other Texas settings use the word more narrowly, so the source of the de novo right controls what actually happens at the hearing.

Appeals from justice court: a new trial in county court

Under Government Code Section 27.031, justice courts have original jurisdiction over civil matters in which the amount in controversy is not more than 20,000 dollars, excluding interest. Small claims cases, defined in Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 500.1(a), are one type of case heard there.

A party who loses in justice court can appeal to the county court, and Rule 506.3 says the case must be tried de novo there. Both sides start over: witnesses testify again, evidence is offered again, and the county court decides the case on its own. For an injury claim, that means the plaintiff must again prove the elements of negligence.

Deadline and bond for a justice court appeal

Rule 506.1 gives a party 21 days after the judgment is signed to appeal, or 21 days after a motion to reinstate, motion to set aside or motion for new trial is denied. The appeal is taken by filing a bond, making a cash deposit, or filing a Statement of Inability to Afford Payment of Court Costs with the justice court.

Under the same rule, a plaintiff's appeal bond is 500 dollars, and a defendant's bond is twice the amount of the judgment. The appeal is perfected when the bond, deposit or statement is filed, and an appellant who posts a bond or deposit must serve written notice of the appeal on the other parties within 7 days. The county court may not render a default judgment against the appellant without first finding full compliance with the rule, and an appeal may not be dismissed for a procedural defect without 7 days' notice and a chance to correct it.

Associate judge rulings and the referring court

Chapter 54A of the Government Code lets district courts and statutory county courts assigned civil cases use associate judges (Section 54A.101). Under Section 54A.106, a judge may refer any civil case or portion of one to an associate judge, although a party can file a written objection to having the trial on the merits referred.

Under Section 54A.115, any party may request a de novo hearing before the referring court by filing a written request with the clerk within seven working days after receiving notice of the associate judge's decision. The request must list the issues, the hearing is limited to those issues, and the court must hold it within 30 days after the first request is filed. Family cases follow a separate statute, Family Code Section 201.015, with a deadline of the third working day after notice.

What happens at an associate judge de novo hearing

Once one party asks for a de novo hearing, Section 54A.115 gives any other party seven working days after the first request to file its own request. The requesting party must also give notice to the opposing attorney under Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 21a.

At the hearing, the parties may present witnesses on the issues listed in the request, and the referring court may consider the record of the associate judge's hearing, including any jury charge and verdict, if a court reporter made one. A party may not demand a second jury if the associate judge's proposed order or judgment came from a jury trial.

Workers' compensation: modified de novo review

A party who disagrees with an appeals panel decision of the Division of Workers' Compensation can take the dispute to court. Labor Code Section 410.252 requires the suit to be filed within 45 days after the division mailed the decision, and the mailing date is deemed to be the fifth day after the decision was filed. Whether a job injury is a comp claim, a negligence claim or both depends on the facts; see who can file a construction accident claim in Texas.

For compensability and income or death benefit disputes, the Supreme Court of Texas called this modified de novo review in Texas Workers' Compensation Commission v. Garcia (1995). The trial is limited to issues the appeals panel decided (Section 410.302), the appealing party must prove its case by a preponderance of the evidence (Section 410.303), and the court must inform the jury of the panel's decision on each disputed issue (Section 410.304), though Garcia noted the jury need not give it any particular weight. Other issues are reviewed under the substantial evidence rule (Section 410.255).

De novo review on appeal

The phrase also describes how a court of appeals reviews some issues after a trial. In State v. Shumake (2006), the Supreme Court of Texas said that statutory construction is a question of law, and that its review is accordingly de novo. Under that standard, the appellate court gives no deference to how the trial court read the statute.

De novo review is not a new trial. The appellate court works from the record of the earlier proceeding and decides the legal question itself, without deferring to the trial court's conclusion. A trial de novo, by contrast, is a complete rehearing with live evidence.

What a de novo notice means for an injury case

The first step is to identify which kind of de novo proceeding a notice or ruling describes, because each has its own source and its own deadline. A justice court appeal, an associate judge review and a workers' compensation suit all run on short clocks, measured in days or working days.

Because a de novo trial or hearing sets the earlier result aside, it can reopen settlement talks; see mediation in personal injury cases and how many personal injury cases go to trial. For starting a case in district court, see how to file a personal injury lawsuit, and for other court terms, the Legal Guides hub.

Summary

De novo means anew: the court decides the matter itself instead of deferring to an earlier ruling. In a Texas justice court appeal, Rule 506.3 requires a full new trial in county court, and Rule 506.1 sets a 21-day deadline to appeal. A civil associate judge's decision can be reheard by the referring court on a request filed within seven working days under Government Code Section 54A.115. Workers' compensation suits over compensability and benefits get modified de novo review, and appellate courts review questions of law de novo.

Where de novo shows up in Texas civil cases
SettingWhat happensTime to actSource
Appeal from justice courtNew trial in county court, as if there had been no previous trial21 days after judgment is signed or a post-judgment motion is deniedTRCP 506.1, 506.3
Civil associate judge decisionHearing before the referring court on the issues listed7 working days after notice of the decisionGov't Code 54A.115
Family associate judge reportHearing before the referring court on the issues listedThird working day after noticeFamily Code 201.015
Workers' comp appeals panel decision (compensability, benefits)Modified de novo trial; jury is told the panel's decision45 days after the decision is mailedLabor Code 410.252, 410.301 to 410.304; Garcia (1995)
Appellate review of a legal questionCourt of appeals decides the legal issue itselfNot a separate filing stepState v. Shumake (2006)

Frequently asked questions

A de novo hearing is a fresh hearing in which a court decides the issues itself, without being bound by an earlier ruling. De novo is Latin for anew. In Texas, the details depend on the source of the right: a justice court appeal is a complete new trial, while a hearing after an associate judge's decision covers only the issues listed in the request.

Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 506.1 allows 21 days after the judgment is signed, or 21 days after a motion to reinstate, set aside or for new trial is denied. The appeal is made by filing a bond, a cash deposit or a Statement of Inability to Afford Payment of Court Costs with the justice court. The case is then tried de novo in county court.

In a trial de novo from justice court, yes: Rule 506.3 says the entire case is presented as if there had been no previous trial. At a de novo hearing after a civil associate judge's decision, Government Code Section 54A.115 lets parties present witnesses on the issues listed in the request, and the court may also consider the record of the associate judge's hearing.

It is the court review that applies to compensability and income or death benefit disputes after an appeals panel decision. The trial is limited to issues the panel decided, the appealing party must prove its case by a preponderance of the evidence, and the court tells the jury what the panel decided. The Supreme Court of Texas used the term in Texas Workers' Compensation Commission v. Garcia.

No. When a Texas appellate court reviews a question of law de novo, such as the meaning of a statute, it decides the legal question itself without deferring to the trial court's conclusion. It works from the existing record rather than holding a new trial. A trial de novo, by contrast, is a complete rehearing of the case, as in a justice court appeal to county court.

The Valentine Law Firm handles Texas personal injury cases. This guide is general information about Texas law, not legal advice.

Was someone hurt in a crash?

If a collision or injury is behind your question, The Valentine Law Firm offers a free consultation on where you stand.

Contingency fee. You pay nothing unless we win.

Call Now Free Consultation