What Is a Civil Lawsuit, and How Is It Different From a Criminal Case in Texas?

A civil lawsuit is a case a person or business files against another to recover money for a harm, such as an injury caused by a careless driver. A criminal case is brought by the State to punish an offense. This guide covers who brings each case in Texas, the standards of proof, how one crash can lead to both, and how a civil suit starts.

  • 138Google reviews
  • 3Attorneys on your case
  • 2 yrsTexas filing deadline
  • No feeUnless we win

What a civil lawsuit is

A civil lawsuit is a dispute between private parties that a court resolves. The person who files is the plaintiff, and the person or company being sued is the defendant. In an injury case, the plaintiff asks for money damages for losses caused by the defendant's conduct, the basic shape of every personal injury claim.

Civil Practice and Remedies Code Section 41.001 defines economic damages as compensation for actual economic or pecuniary loss, and noneconomic damages as compensation for losses such as physical pain, mental anguish, disfigurement and physical impairment. Most injury suits are negligence claims, so they turn on the elements of negligence. Related court terms are collected in the Legal Guides hub.

Who brings a civil case and who brings a criminal case

In a civil case, the injured person decides whether to sue, whom to sue and whether to accept a settlement. A criminal case belongs to the State. Code of Criminal Procedure Articles 21.02 and 21.21 require an indictment or an information to begin "In the name and by authority of The State of Texas," and Article 21.20 describes an information as a charge filed on behalf of the State by the district or county attorney.

In the criminal case, the person hurt is a victim and often a witness, while the prosecutor presents the case. In the civil case, the same person is the plaintiff and directs the claim.

Burden of proof: preponderance versus reasonable doubt

A civil jury decides most questions by a preponderance of the evidence. The jury instructions prescribed under Rule 226a of the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure define that term as the greater weight of credible evidence, and tell jurors that a fact is proved this way if they find it more likely true than not true.

The criminal standard is far higher. Penal Code Section 2.01 presumes every person innocent and bars a conviction unless each element of the offense is proved beyond a reasonable doubt. It also says an arrest or charge gives rise to no inference of guilt.

Civil law has a middle standard for punishment-style awards. Under Civil Practice and Remedies Code Section 41.003, exemplary damages, often called punitive damages, require clear and convincing evidence of fraud, malice or gross negligence, meaning proof that produces a firm belief or conviction. Rule 292 lets 10 of 12 jurors return most civil verdicts, but exemplary damages need a unanimous jury.

Money damages versus punishment

A civil judgment orders the defendant to pay the plaintiff. A criminal conviction leads to a sentence. Penal Code Section 49.07, for example, makes intoxication assault, causing serious bodily injury to another by reason of intoxication while operating a motor vehicle in a public place, a felony of the third degree.

The line is not perfectly clean. Section 41.001 defines exemplary damages as damages awarded as a penalty or by way of punishment. Section 41.008 caps them, but the cap does not apply when the claim rests on felony conduct listed in that section, including intoxication assault and intoxication manslaughter. These rules matter most in drunk driving accident claims.

One crash, two cases

If a drunk driver seriously injures someone, the State may prosecute intoxication assault while the injured person files a civil suit against the driver. The cases run in separate court files with different parties. Whether a particular crash involves a crime at all is covered in whether a car accident is a crime.

The criminal court can order restitution. Code of Criminal Procedure Article 42.037(b)(2) allows the sentencing court, when an offense causes personal injury, to order the defendant to pay the victim for expenses incurred as a result of the offense. The State or the victim can enforce that order in the same manner as a civil judgment.

Restitution is not a substitute for the civil claim. Article 42.037(f)(2) reduces any later civil recovery from the defendant by the restitution already paid, and pain and mental anguish, which the restitution article does not list, are recovered as noneconomic damages in the civil suit.

Can a criminal conviction or plea be used in the civil case?

It depends on the plea. Texas Rule of Evidence 410(a) bars using a nolo contendere plea, also called a no contest plea, against the defendant who made it in a civil case. The same rule excludes a withdrawn guilty plea and statements from plea discussions that did not end in a guilty plea.

A felony conviction is treated differently. Rule of Evidence 803(22) keeps the hearsay rule from excluding a final felony conviction offered in a civil case to prove a fact essential to the judgment, if it followed a trial or a guilty plea and no appeal is pending. Article 42.037(l) adds that a conviction for an offense involving the act that gave rise to restitution stops the defendant from denying the essential allegations of that offense in a later civil suit by the victim, to the extent consistent with state law.

A not-guilty verdict is not a civil finding. It means the State did not prove each element beyond a reasonable doubt, a different question from whether a fact is more likely true than not.

Deadlines for a civil injury lawsuit

Civil Practice and Remedies Code Section 16.003 requires a personal injury suit to be brought not later than two years after the day the cause of action accrues. For injury resulting in death, the period is also two years, and the cause of action accrues on the death of the injured person.

Section 16.003 does not pause the two-year deadline while a criminal case is pending, so waiting for a prosecution to end can use up the time to file. Exceptions and special rules are collected in the guide to the Texas statute of limitations.

How a civil lawsuit starts in Texas

Under Rule 22 of the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure, a civil suit in district court or county court begins with a petition filed with the clerk. Rules 47 and 79 require the petition to name the parties, give a short statement of the claim, say the damages are within the court's jurisdictional limits, and state a bracket of relief, such as only monetary relief of 325,000 dollars or less.

The clerk issues a citation on request under Rule 99, and the plaintiff is responsible for having it served with the petition. The citation is styled "The State of Texas" even though the case is civil. It tells the defendant to file a written answer by 10:00 a.m. on the Monday after 20 days have passed from service, or risk a default judgment.

Smaller disputes can go to justice court, where Rule 500.1 allows a small claims case for no more than 20,000 dollars, excluding statutory interest and court costs but including attorney fees. The practical steps before and after filing are covered in how to file a personal injury lawsuit.

Summary

A civil lawsuit is brought by the injured person to recover money damages, while a criminal case is brought in the name of the State of Texas to punish an offense. Most civil questions are decided by a preponderance of the evidence, while a conviction needs proof beyond a reasonable doubt under Penal Code Section 2.01. One crash can lead to both cases, but criminal restitution for a personal injury covers the victim's expenses caused by the offense, and any amount paid is credited against a later civil recovery. A personal injury suit generally must be filed within two years under Section 16.003.

Civil lawsuit and criminal case compared
QuestionCivil lawsuitCriminal case
Who brings itThe injured person, as plaintiffThe State, through the district or county attorney
How it startsPetition filed with the clerk, then citation and serviceIndictment or information in the name of the State
Standard of proofMore likely true than notBeyond a reasonable doubt
PunishmentExemplary damages: clear and convincing evidence, unanimous jurySentence after conviction
What the injured person can receiveEconomic and noneconomic damagesRestitution of expenses, if ordered
Injury filing deadlineTwo years from accrual for most suitsNot tied to the civil deadline

Frequently asked questions

A civil lawsuit is a court case between private parties in which the plaintiff asks the court to order the defendant to pay money or provide other relief for a harm. Personal injury claims are civil lawsuits. In Texas, a civil suit in district or county court starts with a petition filed with the clerk, followed by service of a citation on the defendant.

A civil case is brought by the injured person to recover money damages, and most questions are decided by a preponderance of the evidence, meaning more likely true than not. A criminal case is brought in the name of the State of Texas to punish an offense, and Penal Code Section 2.01 requires each element to be proved beyond a reasonable doubt.

Yes. A civil suit starts with the injured person's own petition, and neither the Texas filing rules nor the two-year limitations statute requires a criminal charge first. The civil claim is decided on its own evidence under the civil standard of proof, which asks whether a fact is more likely true than not.

Evidence of the plea itself is not admissible against the person who made it. Texas Rule of Evidence 410(a) bars evidence of a nolo contendere plea against that defendant in a civil case. A final felony conviction entered after a trial or a guilty plea is different: Rule 803(22) keeps the hearsay rule from excluding it when offered to prove a fact essential to the judgment, if no appeal is pending.

No. Under Code of Criminal Procedure Article 42.037, a sentencing court may order a defendant to pay an injured victim's expenses caused by the offense. Noneconomic losses such as pain and mental anguish belong to the civil claim, and any restitution already paid is subtracted from what the victim later recovers from that defendant in a civil case.

Civil Practice and Remedies Code Section 16.003 generally requires a personal injury suit to be filed within two years after the day the cause of action accrues. A claim for injury resulting in death also has two years, running from the date of death. That section does not pause the deadline while a criminal case is pending, so waiting for a prosecution to finish can use up the time to file.

The Valentine Law Firm handles Texas personal injury cases. This guide is general information about Texas law, not legal advice.

Was someone hurt in a crash?

If a collision or injury is behind your question, The Valentine Law Firm offers a free consultation on where you stand.

Contingency fee. You pay nothing unless we win.

Call Now Free Consultation