Is a Car Accident a Crime in Texas?
An ordinary collision is not a crime. Specific conduct around one can be, and where charges are brought a criminal case runs on its own track alongside the civil claim without deciding it.
- 138Google reviews
- 3Attorneys on your case
- 2 yrsTexas filing deadline
- No feeUnless we win
Ordinary negligence is not criminal
Failing to keep a proper lookout, following too closely, misjudging a gap: these are civil matters. They give rise to a claim for damages, not to prosecution.
Traffic citations sit in between. A citation for an offense such as failure to control speed is a criminal matter procedurally in Texas but is not what most people mean by a crime, and it does not by itself establish civil liability.
Where a collision does become criminal
Driving while intoxicated, and the aggravated forms where someone is seriously injured or killed: intoxication assault and intoxication manslaughter. Criminally negligent homicide, where conduct fell substantially below the standard of an ordinary person.
Failure to stop and render aid, which criminalizes leaving the scene rather than causing the collision. Racing on a highway. Driving with a suspended license in some circumstances.
The two cases are separate and prove different things
A criminal prosecution asks whether the state can prove an offense beyond reasonable doubt. A civil claim asks whether the claimant can prove negligence by a preponderance of the evidence, which is a materially lower standard.
So an acquittal does not defeat a civil claim, and a decision not to prosecute does not mean nobody was negligent. Prosecutors decline charges for reasons that have nothing to do with civil liability.
What a conviction does for a civil claim
A conviction for a serious offense may be admissible and is persuasive, particularly to a jury. Where intoxication is established, it also supports a gross negligence argument and therefore exemplary damages.
It does not automatically establish civil liability. The elements differ and the civil case still has to be proved, though a conviction makes that considerably easier.
Why waiting for the criminal case is a mistake
Criminal proceedings can take a long time and prosecutors control evidence in the meantime, which can slow civil discovery. Meanwhile the civil limitations period keeps running.
Families frequently wait for a criminal case to conclude before taking civil advice and lose both time and evidence. The two can and usually should proceed in parallel.
Restitution is not compensation
A criminal court may order restitution, and it is not the same as civil damages. Restitution is typically limited to quantifiable economic loss and is constrained by what the defendant can pay.
It does not cover pain, mental anguish, impairment or disfigurement, and accepting it does not resolve the civil claim, though how the two interact should be checked.
Summary
| Criminal case | Civil claim | |
|---|---|---|
| Question asked | Was an offense committed | Was there negligence |
| Standard of proof | Beyond reasonable doubt | Preponderance of the evidence |
| Brought by | The state | The injured person |
| Outcome | Punishment, possible restitution | Damages |
| Acquittal | No conviction | Civil claim unaffected |
| Conviction | Punishment | Persuasive, not automatic liability |
Keep reading
Cedar Park Car Accident Lawyer
A car accident claim in Texas turns on two questions: who was responsible, and what did the collision actually cost you.
Practice areaWhat To Do After a Car Accident in Texas
The decisions that matter most are made in the first hour, when you are least equipped to make them.
ReadDelayed Injury Symptoms After a Car Accident
Walking away from a collision does not mean you were not hurt.
ReadDrunk Driving Accident Claims in Texas
A drunk driving collision produces two cases. The State prosecutes the driver, and you bring a separate civil claim.
ReadRain Related Car Accidents in Central Texas
Rain does not excuse a collision.
ReadUninsured and Underinsured Motorist Claims
When the driver who hit you has no insurance, or nowhere near enough, the recovery usually comes from your own policy.
Read
Frequently asked questions
An ordinary collision caused by negligence is not. Specific conduct can be criminal: driving while intoxicated, intoxication assault or manslaughter, criminally negligent homicide, failure to stop and render aid, and racing.
No. A criminal case must be proved beyond reasonable doubt, while a civil claim needs only a preponderance of the evidence. Prosecutors decline charges for reasons unconnected to civil liability.
Generally not. Criminal proceedings can take a long time and can slow civil discovery, while the civil limitations period keeps running and evidence perishes. The two usually proceed in parallel.
No. Restitution ordered by a criminal court is typically limited to quantifiable economic loss and constrained by what the defendant can pay. It does not cover pain, mental anguish, impairment or disfigurement.
Talk it through with a lawyer
A free consultation covers whether you have a claim, what the deadline is, and what insurance is actually available.
Contingency fee. You pay nothing unless we win.