Slip and Fall on Ice in Texas
Texas has an unusual position on naturally accumulating ice, and it defeats a great many claims. What makes the difference is whether the ice was natural or was created by something the occupier did.
- 138Google reviews
- 3Attorneys on your case
- 2 yrsTexas filing deadline
- No feeUnless we win
The natural accumulation rule
Texas courts have generally held that an occupier owes no duty to protect or warn against ice that accumulated naturally. Precipitation freezing on an untreated surface is treated as a condition everyone knows about and can guard against.
That is a stricter position than many states take, and it is the reason a large proportion of winter fall claims in Texas fail at the duty stage rather than on notice or on damages.
Unnatural accumulation is different
Where the occupier's own conduct created or worsened the ice, the rule does not apply. A downspout discharging across a walkway, a leaking gutter, a sprinkler running in freezing conditions, a faulty drain pooling water, or an HVAC unit dripping onto a path.
Partial or negligent treatment can also create an unnatural condition: salting part of an area so that meltwater refreezes elsewhere, or clearing a path badly so that a compacted ridge forms. The distinction is fact-specific and it is the whole case.
Ice inside the building
Water tracked in from outside is not natural accumulation once it is on an interior floor. Entrance areas during a freeze are among the most productive premises claims in Texas.
The questions are ordinary ones: whether mats were placed, whether the area was monitored and dried, whether warning signage was used, and how long the water had been there. Constructive knowledge applies normally.
Why Texas freezes produce so many claims
Infrastructure and habits are not built for it. Sustained freezes are infrequent enough that many businesses have no winter protocol at all, no salt or sand on hand, and no procedure for monitoring entrances.
That absence is itself evidence. Where a business had no plan and no supplies during a forecast freeze, the failure to exercise reasonable care is easier to establish than the natural accumulation rule might suggest.
What to preserve, and quickly
Photographs of the ice itself, immediately, including its extent and any source such as a downspout or sprinkler head above it. Ice melts, and within hours there is no evidence any condition existed.
Weather records for the location and period, which establish whether precipitation was actually falling or whether the water came from somewhere else. That single distinction decides which rule applies.
Where a governmental unit is involved
Falls on public sidewalks, in public buildings or in municipal parking areas involve governmental units. The Texas Tort Claims Act applies with formal written notice required within months and damages capped.
Cities also frequently shift sidewalk maintenance obligations to adjoining property owners by ordinance, which can make a private owner the correct defendant for a public sidewalk.
Summary
| Source of the ice | Usual position |
|---|---|
| Precipitation freezing on an untreated surface | No duty, natural accumulation |
| Downspout or gutter discharging onto a walkway | Unnatural, duty applies |
| Sprinkler running in freezing conditions | Unnatural, duty applies |
| Leaking pipe or faulty drain | Unnatural, duty applies |
| Partial or negligent clearing | Can create an unnatural condition |
| Water tracked inside a building | Ordinary premises rules apply |
Keep reading
Texas Premises Liability Lawyer
A property owner is not automatically responsible when someone is hurt on their land.
Practice areaTrampoline Park Injury Claims in Texas
Trampoline parks require a signed waiver before anyone is allowed to jump.
ReadSlip and Fall Claims in Texas
A slip and fall claim in Texas rarely turns on whether the floor was dangerous.
ReadSettlements Without Surgery
Surgery is the single largest variable in a slip and fall claim, so a case that resolves without it is valued on a different basis.
ReadPremises Liability Lawsuits in Texas
Most premises claims settle. Suit becomes necessary when the occupier disputes that it knew about...
ReadWhat To Do After a Slip and Fall
The hazard that caused the fall will be cleaned up within minutes and the footage overwritten within days.
Read
Frequently asked questions
Generally not where the ice accumulated naturally from precipitation, because Texas courts have held that no duty arises. Where the occupier's own conduct created or worsened the ice, such as a downspout or sprinkler discharging onto a walkway, the rule does not apply.
Ice created or worsened by something the occupier did: a downspout or gutter discharging onto a path, a sprinkler running in freezing conditions, a leaking drain, or partial clearing that causes meltwater to refreeze elsewhere.
That is not natural accumulation once it is on an interior floor, and ordinary premises rules apply. Entrance areas during a freeze are among the more productive premises claims in Texas.
The ice itself immediately, its extent, and anything above it that might be the source such as a downspout or sprinkler head. Ice melts within hours and then no evidence the condition existed remains.
Talk it through with a lawyer
A free consultation covers whether you have a claim, what the deadline is, and what insurance is actually available.
Contingency fee. You pay nothing unless we win.