What Does an Insurance Adjuster Do After a Texas Car Accident?
An insurance adjuster is the person an insurance company assigns to investigate a claim, review what happened and estimate what the company will pay. After a Texas crash, the adjuster for your own insurer and the adjuster for the other driver's insurer owe you different things. This guide explains adjuster types, recorded statements, unfair settlement practices and how to complain to the state.
- 138Google reviews
- 3Attorneys on your case
- 2 yrsTexas filing deadline
- No feeUnless we win
What an insurance adjuster does
An insurance claims adjuster reviews what happened, decides whether the policy covers the loss and estimates the payment. The Texas Department of Insurance (TDI) describes the adjuster as someone who works for the insurance company paying the claim and who may inspect the damage, read police reports, talk to witnesses and ask for more information.
TDI's auto insurance guide says the company bases its payment on the adjuster's estimate, which can be raised if the damage proves worse than first thought. How an insurer turns injuries into a number is covered in how insurance companies calculate an injury settlement, and other claim concepts are collected in the Legal Guides hub.
Staff, independent and public adjusters in Texas
Texas licenses adjusters under Insurance Code Chapter 4101. Section 4101.001 defines an adjuster as a person who investigates or adjusts losses on behalf of an insurer, either as an independent contractor or as an employee of an insurer, an adjustment bureau or certain agents, and also a person who supervises the handling of claims. Section 4101.051 bars anyone from acting as an adjuster in Texas without a license, subject to the chapter's exceptions.
A staff adjuster is the insurer's own employee and an independent adjuster is hired from outside, but both act for the insurer. Section 4101.002 exempts a few groups, including public insurance adjusters, who have their own chapter.
A public insurance adjuster, licensed under Chapter 4102, works the other way. Section 4102.001 describes someone paid to act on behalf of an insured on a claim for loss or damage under a policy covering real or personal property. Section 4102.103 requires a written contract stating that the adjuster represents the insured only, which the client may cancel in writing within 72 hours, and Section 4102.104 caps the commission at 10 percent of the settlement. Section 4102.003 adds that the chapter does not entitle anyone to practice law.
Your insurer's adjuster and the other driver's adjuster
Your own insurer's adjuster handles claims under a contract you bought, such as collision, personal injury protection or uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage. The other driver's adjuster handles a liability claim against that company's policyholder. TDI points out that you have no contract with the other driver's insurer, so you do not have the same options you would have with your own company.
Texas law reflects this. Section 541.060(a) applies its list of unfair settlement practices to a claim by an insured or beneficiary, and Section 541.060(b) says that list gives no cause of action to a third party claiming against someone covered by a liability policy. TDI still says the other driver's insurer must act in good faith and try to settle quickly and fairly, though the prompt payment law does not apply to it.
Reporting the crash to your own company is a separate question from claiming against the other driver, which the guide on whether to call your own insurer when the crash was not your fault explains. How shared fault affects what either adjuster offers is covered in the guide to Texas comparative negligence.
Recorded statements and the cooperation clause
A recorded statement is an account of the crash that an adjuster records, often by phone, for the claim file. Whether any duty applies depends on whose adjuster asks.
The insurer-published Texas personal auto policy forms reviewed for this guide include a part titled Duties After an Accident or Loss. It requires a person seeking coverage to cooperate in the investigation, settlement or defense of any claim or suit, and the forms reviewed also require physical exams by doctors the insurer selects, and one requires recorded statements under oath when the insurer reasonably asks. Wording varies by insurer, so the policy itself controls.
That cooperation duty is a term of your own contract. Because there is no contract with the other driver's insurer, its request for a statement is not backed by a policy duty you owe it. Common missteps in early conversations with insurers are covered in mistakes to avoid after a car accident.
Unfair settlement practices under Section 541.060
Insurance Code Chapter 541 prohibits unfair or deceptive acts in the business of insurance, and Section 541.002 includes adjusters in the people it covers. Section 541.060(a) lists unfair settlement practices for a claim by an insured or beneficiary.
The list includes misrepresenting a material fact or policy provision about coverage; failing to attempt in good faith a prompt, fair and equitable settlement once liability has become reasonably clear; failing to promptly give a reasonable explanation for a denial or a compromise offer; failing within a reasonable time to affirm or deny coverage or send a reservation of rights; and refusing to pay without a reasonable investigation.
It also covers enforcing a full and final release after only partial payment, unless the payment compromises a doubtful or disputed claim, and demanding federal income tax returns to settle, with narrow exceptions. Section 541.151 lets a person who suffers actual damages from these practices bring a lawsuit, subject to the third-party limit in Section 541.060(b).
Offers, releases and disagreements with an adjuster
TDI's guide says that when another driver caused the injury, that driver's insurer will offer a settlement for related medical bills and ask for a signed release promising no further claims for the accident. TDI suggests talking with a doctor about future treatment before signing, because the release ends the claim.
If you disagree with an adjuster's estimate, TDI suggests telling the company why with supporting documents, and notes you can ask for a different adjuster. Your own policy may include an appraisal process, in which each side hires an appraiser and an umpire decides if their estimates differ; TDI describes it for disputes with your own insurer. When an adjuster splits blame, the guide to fighting a 50/50 fault decision explains how that position is tested; the car accident claim page covers the wider process.
How to complain to TDI about an adjuster
TDI says it can help with complaints against the insurance companies, agents and adjusters it regulates. Its Help Line is 800-252-3439, and it asks people to raise the issue with the company first. A complaint must be in writing; TDI's online Complaint Portal is one way to file, with documents such as photos and letters.
TDI then asks the company for a response and explains it to the consumer. TDI cannot decide fault, set damage amounts, or make a company pay unless nonpayment violates a law or the policy.
Complaints about the other driver's insurer are harder. TDI's auto complaint page lists complaints against another person's insurer among those it can't help with; its page on dealing with the other driver's insurer says a company you complain about must write back explaining a denial or payment. Broader help with an injury claim is gathered on the dealing with insurance in a Texas injury claim page.
Summary
Staff and independent adjusters investigate and adjust losses on behalf of an insurer, and Insurance Code Chapter 4101 requires them to be licensed in Texas, with exceptions. A public insurance adjuster licensed under Chapter 4102 works for the insured on property claims, not for the company. Your own insurer's adjuster handles a claim under a contract you hold, while the other driver's adjuster represents a company you have no contract with. Section 541.060 lists unfair settlement practices for claims by an insured, and the Texas Department of Insurance takes written complaints about companies and adjusters it regulates.
| Adjuster | Who they work for | Texas law | What it means for an injured driver |
|---|---|---|---|
| Staff adjuster | The insurer, as its employee | Licensed under Insurance Code Chapter 4101 | Works for whichever company employs them, yours or the other driver's |
| Independent adjuster | The insurer, as an outside contractor or adjustment bureau | Licensed under Insurance Code Chapter 4101 | Acts for the company that hired them; not a neutral party |
| Public insurance adjuster | The insured, under a written contract | Licensed under Insurance Code Chapter 4102; commission capped at 10 percent | Defined around property policy claims of the insured, not a claim against another driver |
| Your own insurer's adjuster | Your insurance company | Unfair settlement practices in Section 541.060 apply to claims by an insured | Your policy's cooperation clause applies to you |
| Other driver's insurer's adjuster | The other driver's insurance company | Under Section 541.060(b), the 541.060(a) list gives a third-party claimant no cause of action | No contract with you, so no policy duty to cooperate with it |
Keep reading
Legal Guides
The core legal ideas behind a Texas injury claim, in plain language: what negligence means...
Guide hubThe Four Elements of Negligence in Texas
To hold someone responsible for an injury in Texas, you have to prove four things: that they owed you...
ReadIs Settlement Money Taxable? Injury Claims and Taxes
Settlement money paid for a physical injury or physical sickness is generally not taxable under federal...
ReadGross Negligence vs Ordinary Negligence in Texas
Ordinary negligence is carelessness, like a driver who was not paying attention.
ReadCedar Park Wrongful Death Lawyer
Texas injury representation for wrongful death.
Practice area
Frequently asked questions
An insurance adjuster investigates a claim for an insurance company, decides whether the policy covers the loss and estimates what the company should pay. The Texas Department of Insurance says adjusters may inspect damage, read police reports, talk to witnesses and ask for more information. In a car accident claim the company usually bases its payment on the adjuster's estimate, which can be revised if new damage or information comes to light.
The insurer-published Texas personal auto policy forms reviewed for this guide require a person seeking coverage to cooperate with their own insurer, and that duty comes from the policy contract. The Texas Department of Insurance notes that you have no contract with the other driver's insurer, so its request for a recorded statement is not backed by a policy duty you owe it. Your own policy's wording, which varies by insurer, controls the duties you owe your own company.
Staff and independent adjusters investigate and adjust losses on behalf of an insurer under Texas Insurance Code Chapter 4101, so they act for the company. Your own insurer owes you duties under your policy, and Section 541.060 lists unfair settlement practices for claims by an insured. The other driver's adjuster represents that driver's insurer, and Section 541.060(b) gives a third-party claimant no cause of action under that list.
A public insurance adjuster is licensed under Texas Insurance Code Chapter 4102 and is paid to act for the insured, not the insurer, on claims for loss or damage under a policy covering real or personal property. The contract must be in writing, state that the adjuster represents the insured only, and allow cancellation within 72 hours. The commission cannot exceed 10 percent of the settlement, and the license does not allow the adjuster to practice law.
The Texas Department of Insurance takes complaints about the companies, agents and adjusters it regulates. It suggests first raising the problem with the company, then filing a written complaint, for example through its online Complaint Portal, with supporting documents. Its auto complaint page says it cannot help with complaints against another person's insurer. TDI contacts the company for a response and explains it to you. It cannot decide fault or set damage amounts, and its Help Line is 800-252-3439.
The Valentine Law Firm handles Texas personal injury cases. This guide is general information about Texas law, not legal advice.
Was someone hurt in a crash?
If a collision or injury is behind your question, The Valentine Law Firm offers a free consultation on where you stand.
Contingency fee. You pay nothing unless we win.